search

offa / android-foss

A list of Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) for Android – saving Freedom and Privacy.
https://offa.github.io/android-foss/
GNU General Public License v3.0
5.88k stars 264 forks source link

Magisk Modules List? #307

Open offa opened 1 year ago

offa commented 1 year ago

Should we add a list of FOSS Magisk modules (same criteria as now)?

They are a topic of their own and I'm not sure whether they fit into the main list. However, maintaining such a list might be handy.

Also of interest: Is there a suitable list already?

farline99 commented 1 year ago

There are currently 2 biggest repositories with Magisk modules. They are Androidacy and Alternative. I think we should create a separate section with links to these repositories instead of listing modules. By the way, from the first, the biggest one, devs are now switching to the second one because of poor management.

shuvashish76 commented 1 year ago

create a separate section with links to these repositories instead of listing modules

IMO we should either add those two repo links in current list because they already listed modules 👍🏻(or create a separate file for modules only 👎🏻). Complete list with their own category means require additional maintenance i.e. check if archived/abandoned/inactive etc. Not worth for the effort because this kind of list aren't for general users & those who use modules already know where to find them.

farline99 commented 1 year ago

@shuvashish76 i mean create new category Magisk Modules in README.md. not to create new file or list of course 😬😃

offa commented 1 year ago

I +1 for linking the existing lists rather than maintaining another one.Thanks @farline99 for bringing up those two. Fully agree with @shuvashish76.