search

officialchengyud / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

Setting reminders allow me to set a reminder from the past #3

Open officialchengyud opened 2 months ago

officialchengyud commented 2 months ago

Outline: In the UserGuide it states that Set reminders for important deadlines or milestones(e.g. O-Levels, A-Levels).

This leads me to believe that the feature should prevent me from accidentally setting a reminder that has already passed (especially since you don't want the user to accidentally set the wrong deadline for an important milestone like O-Levels/A-Levels).

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Enter remind n/Bob uni app deadline at/2022-03-04 12:00 t/urgent
  2. The TutorPro app will allow deadlines in the past.

Why low severity This is not an issue if users are careful. Even if they set the wrong date, they can still continue to use the app. However it is an inconvenience (they may miss an important deadline).

Screenshot

Screenshot 2024-04-19 at 4.31.02 PM.png

nus-se-bot commented 2 months ago

Team's Response

This feature actually allows users to track what events/reminders have already passed, as some users may want to keep track of the work they have done using the app

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue response

Team chose [response.Rejected]

Reason for disagreement: I think you have mistaken what a reminder means. It is not a reminder if it does not remind you. It could simply just be a notes app. From my perspective, either your UG is extremely unclear, or you are unsure of what you want from this feature (or both).

My observations are:

  1. It is merely a function that provides no value in v1.4
  2. You didn't add a feature to check reminders, so what does this feature do (or what does it bring to your TutorPro app)?

Given these points, I have chosen to disagree.