okfn / opendataeditor

No-code application to explore and publish all kinds of data: datasets, tables, charts, maps, stories, and more. Forever free and open source project powered by open standards and generative AI.
http://opendataeditor.okfn.org
MIT License
149 stars 18 forks source link

Editing process - Yellow color in cells #409

Open romicolman opened 1 month ago

romicolman commented 1 month ago

Problem description

When the user deletes content from a cell/range, the ODE highlights those cells in yellow, as a "warning sign" (empty cells).

Steps to reproduce it

Additional comments

Question for the UX specialist:

roll commented 1 month ago

@romicolman Yellow == any changed cells (that can be reverted or saved)

Empty cells are not highlighted themselves

romicolman commented 2 weeks ago

@roll thanks! Adding additional context here. You are right, @roll it's not an error to have a blank cell in my tabular file. However, I think the the best option in terms of UX is to remove the yellow color whenever a user makes a change. This is not a common practice in other tools and the yellow may be sending the message that "something could be wrong" even if that is not the case. For instance: I opened a csv and edited a number in one of the cells, I just typed a different one. The data type is ok but the yellow color may create some confusion.

romicolman commented 2 weeks ago

One more thing. @Faithkenny: Maybe what we can do if keep the yellow just for those cases when the user types something that goes against the the data type in that column.