search

olive-editor / olive

Free open-source non-linear video editor
https://olivevideoeditor.org/
GNU General Public License v3.0
8.12k stars 547 forks source link

Time interpolation on video clips and on export #1289

Closed leg7 closed 3 years ago

leg7 commented 3 years ago

It would be really cool to add time interpolation settings such as frame blending, optical flow and frame sampling to individual video clips and to the whole video on export.

Here's a video showcasing the three effects in premiere pro: https://youtu.be/jScpocUJGAQ

Tell me if I'm being unclear.

sobotka commented 3 years ago

What part of “No feature requests” is not clear at this point?

Reading is critical.

Simran-B commented 3 years ago

See #1175

leg7 commented 3 years ago

What part of “No feature requests” is not clear at this point?

Reading is critical.

image

Maybe you should chill out and rephrase this so that it says "No feature requests allowed" as you would like it to be instead of "Most feature requests will be rejected".

You can't just expect ppl to read your mind and throw tantrum like an 8 year old when they can't.

Simran-B commented 3 years ago

Adjusted #1175 to "No feature requests" and removed reference to Discord server, which is no longer an official server but only a community platform.

Our current focus is on making Olive 0.2 a stable and usable program for editing video, so we would appreciate if you primarily provide issues that support this goal.

In case it isn't clear: the goal is to make Olive work at all. Things like frame blending, optical flow etc. are way out of scope.

leg7 commented 3 years ago

Adjusted #1175 to "No feature requests" and removed reference to Discord server, which is no longer an official server but only a community platform.

Our current focus is on making Olive 0.2 a stable and usable program for editing video, so we would appreciate if you primarily provide issues that support this goal.

In case it isn't clear: the goal is to make Olive work at all. Things like frame blending, optical flow etc. are way out of scope.

I understand, I thought this would just be added to the backlog. Olive 2.0 instantly crashes for me when I try to add footage to the timeline, will make a report soon.

elsandosgrande commented 3 years ago

I presume that you manually compiled Olive. If your version of FFmpeg is 4.3.0, then you're encountering a know FFmpeg bug which causes Olive to crash whenever you add a video to the timeline (see pinned issue). If your version of FFmpeg is 4.3.1, then it might depend on your operating system whether or not it is affected by the same bug. The 4.3.1 tag in the FFmpeg Git repository hosted by VLAN came four days before the fix for the bug was committed to the repository, yet I am not encountering any crashes with FFmpeg 4.3.1 on Ubuntu Groovy.

Also, a backlog would not make much sense as things may or may not stay similar enough to make going through the backlog worth the effort.

leg7 commented 3 years ago

I presume that you manually compiled Olive. If your version of FFmpeg is 4.3.0, then you're encountering a know FFmpeg bug which causes Olive to crash whenever you add a video to the timeline (see pinned issue). If your version of FFmpeg is 4.3.1, then it might depend on your operating system whether or not it is affected by the same bug. The 4.3.1 tag in the FFmpeg Git repository hosted by VLAN came four days before the fix for the bug was committed to the repository, yet I am not encountering any crashes with FFmpeg 4.3.1 on Ubuntu Groovy. Also, a backlog would not make much sense as things may or may not stay similar enough to make going through the backlog worth the effort.

Olive is crashing when adding footage to the timeline with ffmpeg 4.3.1-2 on Arch Linux 5.9.1-zen2-1-zen. (Olive freshly compiled)

elsandosgrande commented 3 years ago

Yeah, that seems like it's the FFmpeg bug described in the pinned issue. You'll need to either downgrade FFmpeg to the latest version on the 4.2 branch, or get the AppImage from the website.

Now I wonder why I am not affected across any of my six Olive builds in spite of having 4.3.1

On 2020/10/29 15:19, leg7 wrote:

I presume that you manually compiled Olive. If your version of
FFmpeg is 4.3.0, then you're encountering a know FFmpeg bug which
causes Olive to crash whenever you add a video to the timeline
(see pinned issue). If your version of FFmpeg is 4.3.1, then it
might depend on your operating system whether or not it is
affected by the same bug. The 4.3.1 tag in the FFmpeg Git
repository hosted by VLAN came four days before the fix for the
bug was committed to the repository, yet I am not encountering any
crashes with FFmpeg 4.3.1 on Ubuntu Groovy. Also, a backlog would
not make much sense as things may or may not stay similar enough
to make going through the backlog worth the effort.

Olive is crashing when adding footage to the timeline with ffmpeg 4.3.1-2 on Arch Linux 5.9.1-zen2-1-zen. (Olive freshly compiled)

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/olive-editor/olive/issues/1289#issuecomment-718784073, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AJVSPBXTGF5XTJLNZAT5HGTSNF2XLANCNFSM4TCZG3LQ.