search

onaio / onadata

Collect, Analyze and Share
https://ona.io
Other
183 stars 133 forks source link

No error message for relevant expressions referencing future questions #1709

Closed bkimondiu closed 4 years ago

bkimondiu commented 5 years ago

Environment (local, stage, preview, production)

Production

Expected behavior

When an XLSForm is authored and a question is created with a relevant expression that references a future question, an error should be returned when uploading the form to Ona.

Actual behavior

An XLSForm authored with a question that has a relevant expression that references a future question is uploaded successfully to Ona. The question with the relevant expression is hidden when the form is launched (as expected) and shows up when the future question's response satisfies its relevant expression.

Steps to reproduce the behavior

  1. Author an XLSForm with the columns type, name, label and relevant.
  2. Add two questions to the XLSForm e.g. Qn1 and Qn2
  3. Add a relevant expression to Qn1 that references Qn2
  4. Add the form to an Ona account

Find attached an XLSForm for testing

future_relevant.xlsx

Aha! Link: https://ona.aha.io/features/PROD-207

ivermac commented 4 years ago

Hey @lincmba could you please comment why this is a wontfix before we close it?

lincmba commented 4 years ago

@ivermac This was labeled wontfix because it is an expected behavior and not an error.