search

onvif / testspecs

ONVIF Test Specifications
16 stars 9 forks source link

About "No Action element from namespace Addressing10 (http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing). Expected element with value: http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing/soap/fault. " error on "EVENT-3-1-19 v17 5.3.6 REALTIME PULLPOINT SUBSCRIPTION - UNSUBSCRIBE (NEGATIVE TEST)" test case of Onvif Device Test Tool V22.12 #48

Closed madhurao68 closed 4 months ago

madhurao68 commented 11 months ago

Hi, We are facing an issue with developing the ONVIF device event service of profile S. The device test tool keeps showing the error No Action element from namespace Addressing10 (http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing). Expected element with value: http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing/soap/fault.
on EVENT-3-1-19 v17 5.3.6 REALTIME PULLPOINT SUBSCRIPTION - UNSUBSCRIBE (NEGATIVE TEST) test case. Here are the details of the requests and our response. Could you please guide us on how to fix this problem, thank you so much. FIRST

BTW, We also found a similar problem on StackOverflow but still met the same error... https://stackoverflow.com/questions/58843206/error-while-raising-fault-from-the-dut-to-onvif-device-test-tool-in-the-test-cas

fyspkid commented 11 months ago

Hi I posted this question a few weeks ago. Thank @madhurao68 & @HansBusch for helping to transfer my question from spec forum to here. I stuck on this issue for a long time. Could anyone guide me on this issue? Thank you so much!!

madhurao68 commented 11 months ago

Hi The 23.06 version of the test tool was released on the members portal very recently. Work on 23.12 will commence in early August and this issue will be discussed with the test tool vendor and I will keep you posted. Thanks for your patience!

fyspkid commented 11 months ago

Hi madhurao68, Thank you so much for the reply. About the onvif device license certification, could we skip this item of the confomance test on V22.12 first?

thank you so much again and looking forward to your reply.

HansBusch commented 11 months ago

You probably wanted to write 23.06Hans on vacation -------- Original message --------From: Madhu Rao @.> Date: 7/28/23 15:56 (GMT+01:00) To: onvif/testspecs @.> Cc: Hans Busch @.>, Mention @.> Subject: Re: [onvif/testspecs] About "No Action element from namespace Addressing10 (http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing). Expected element with value: http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing/soap/fault. " error on "EVENT-3-1-19 v17 5.3.6 REALTIME PULLPOINT SUBSCRIPTION - UNSUBSCRIBE (NEGATIVE TEST)" test case of Onvif Device Test Tool V22.12 (Issue #48) Hi The 23.12 version of the test tool was released on the members portal very recently. Work on 23.12 will commence in early August and this issue will be discussed with the test tool vendor and I will keep you posted. Thanks for your patience!

—Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

fyspkid commented 11 months ago

Hi madhurao68 & HansBusch The identical error message appears when using the onvif device test tool V23.06 as well. Could we skip this item of the confomance test on V22.12 & V23.06 first?

I appreciate you and look forward to hearing from you.

madhurao68 commented 11 months ago

Hi,

The test EVENT-3-1-19 is an optional test and depends on the features implemented in the device under test. The test is executed in diagnostic mode only. So, this has no bearing on the conformance. You can uncheck the test during the diagnostic test run as well.

To view the description just move the cursor on the test and you will get to see the importance of the test

image

Hope this helps.

LeslieHsia commented 11 months ago

Hi madhura68,

I have a question for you, we are going to make a Profile S product, but I'm a little bit confused about the test items posted below, I had read the Profile S spec and Profile Q spec, these test items below are within the Profile Q scope, but when I execute the conformance test, these items were checked and ready to run, are these test items below within the Profile S scope? Or these items are within the Profile Q scope? monitoring If those test items are within Profile Q, Can I skip these test items?

madhurao68 commented 11 months ago

Profile Q scope,

Hi LeslieHsia,

Profile Q is deprecated, and it is no longer possible to claim conformance for Profile Q. The above tests come under device management and are mandatory if the specified feature is implemented by DUT. So, you can uncheck them if the device does not support the features.

Hope this helps!

fyspkid commented 11 months ago

Hi madhura68, Could you please guide us how to uncheck this monitoring events test cases on conformance test? For example, are there any settings of conformance test could disable/uncheck these test cases? Or should we define anything in our GetService response code? We all set "false" in event device management event capability. Screenshot from 2023-08-15 10-08-47

LeslieHsia commented 10 months ago

Hi madhura68,

Thanks for the rely, it does help!

madhurao68 commented 5 months ago

Hello,

Based on error DTT could not find wsa:Action tag itself (not the value inside the tag). So, the problem is with the tag itself or with related namespace. It is hard to check what exactly went wrong with it based on the screenshot, we need the text log for further analysis.

As for StackOverflow there is another issue. There is additional (") inside the Action tag and issue with the value: "http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing/soap/fault" instead of http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing/soap/fault (without ")