search

open-contracting / cardinal-rs

Measure red flags and procurement indicators using OCDS data
https://cardinal.readthedocs.io
MIT License
9 stars 3 forks source link

R036: Add logic for awardCriteria #27

Open jpmckinney opened 1 year ago

jpmckinney commented 1 year ago

Right now, the indicator just ignores what the awardCriteria is, entirely.

We could add an option to the prepare command to set awardCriteria to 'priceOnly' if the lowest valid bid is awarded.

Camilamila commented 1 year ago

This indicator makes most sense when the criteria is price only, to identify if the lowest bid was disqualified, so thats the preferred option. If we decide to input the awardCriteria to price only when the lowest value is awarded, wouldn't we be missing actually on the flagged procedures (lowest bid disqualified)?

To test with Ecuador, I would suggest to ask SERCOP if they use priceOnly award criteria for specific procurement methods instead and input the value based on that.

jpmckinney commented 1 year ago

wouldn't we be missing actually on the flagged procedures (lowest bid disqualified)?

If the condition is that the lowest valid bid is awarded, then it could still be the case that there are lower disqualified bids.

jpmckinney commented 4 months ago

Noting that we removed this indicator from Ecuador SERCOP per the "Questions and feedback" document, so moving to Post-MVP.