open229 / ruleset-model-description-schema

Developing a schema for ASHRAE Standard 229P.
Other
7 stars 3 forks source link

Constructions need to accommodate more types of insulation values #176

Closed nealkruis closed 1 year ago

nealkruis commented 1 year ago

Some rulesets characterize constructions with multiple R-values, for example:

JasonGlazer commented 1 year ago

@nealkruis we currently have data elements:

What if I make both lists and create a general enumeration of cavity, continuous, slab edge, perimeter. The enumeration and value correspond but can have as long of a list as necessary. What do you think?

We use the list of enumerations and values when we are describing mechanical efficiencies and stuff so it is not a new structure.

Maybe we should split continuous into exterior_continuous and interior_continuous, agree?

Can you think of any other enumeration values?

nealkruis commented 1 year ago

I think this is the right approach. There are a lot of possible combinations of foundation related insulation:

JasonGlazer commented 1 year ago

Based on my somewhat limited knowledge in this area, I came up with the following enumeration. Please let me know what is still missing.

InsulationLocationOptions:
  Object Type: "Enumeration"
  Enumerators:
    ABOVE_GROUND_WALL_EXTERIOR_CONTINUOUS:
      Description: "Continous insulation on exterior of an above ground wall"
    ABOVE_GROUND_WALL_INTERIOR_CONTINUOUS:
      Description: "Continous insulation on interior of an above ground wall"
    ABOVE_GROUND_WALL_FULL_CAVITY:
      Description: "Insulation within the cavity of an above ground wall that fills the entire cavity"
    ABOVE_GROUND_WALL_PARTIAL_CAVITY:
      Description: "Insulation within the cavity of an above ground wall that fills only part of the cavity"
    SLAB_HORIZONTAL_PERIMETER:
      Description: "Insulation on underside of the slab covering the perimeter"
    SLAB_HORIZONTAL_FULL:
      Description: "Insulation fully covering the underside of the slab"
    SLAB_VERTICAL:
      Description: "Insulation applied vertically next to edge of slab"
    NONE:
      Description: "None"
    OTHER:
      Description: "Other"
JasonGlazer commented 1 year ago

@nealkruis if I am missing any enumerations that make sense, please open a new issue for them.