openENTRANCE / openentrance

Definitions of common terms (variables, regions, etc.) for the openENTRANCE project
http://openentrance.eu
Apache License 2.0
30 stars 49 forks source link

Update electricity-grid.yaml #336

Closed sandrinecharousset closed 2 weeks ago

sandrinecharousset commented 2 months ago

add unit EUR_2020/MW to allow using this variable for extension not only of the line length but also of the line capacity

We could also create a new variable whcih I would have named Network|Electricity[Capital Cost for consistance with the investment costs in other technologies which are named Capcital Cost

erikfilias commented 2 months ago

add unit EUR_2020/MW to allow using this variable for extension not only of the line length but also of the line capacity

We could also create a new variable whcih I would have named Network|Electricity[Capital Cost for consistance with the investment costs in other technologies which are named Capcital Cost

Hello, the capital cost variables are in the technology.yaml file. I suggest moving these variables to the electricity-expansion.yaml file and adding this new variable as Capital Cost|Electricity|Network. Finally, I would rename the electricity-expasion.yaml file to invesment.yaml in order to keep the coherence that this file also comprises investment variables related to heat and hydrogen. @sandrinecharousset , @phackstock , How do you see it?

sandrinecharousset commented 2 months ago

@erikfilias sounds good to me The variable name you propose is more consistent with other variable names I am not fully satisfied with having only one capital cost for network expansion in capacity and in length , would be better to separate but could not find a good way of doing it Regarding moving variables from technologies not sure it is a good idea as lots of other models do use these variables and not those in electricity focused yaml files so I would put the new variable maybe in technologies Regarding electricity-expansion from what I remember this is describing variables that are results of electricity capacity expansion models no? No pb to rename it though but I wouldn’t put the capital cost there @danielhuppmann ypu may have an opinion there also? Best

phackstock commented 1 month ago

Thanks @sandrinecharousset and @erikfilias for the discussion and the inputs. @sandrinecharousset I very much agree with you that we should split the variable in two to differentiate between line length and capacity. For naming things I always like to err on the side of verbose but immediately obvious rather than trying to be clever but potentially misleading. Therefore I'd propose something like:

or something along those lines.

sandrinecharousset commented 2 weeks ago

@phackstock could you merge this so that we can upload datasets for the ws with the good unit?