search

openMetadataInitiative / bids2openminds

A tool to generate openMINDS metadata from BIDS datasets
MIT License
1 stars 3 forks source link

Naming convention for dataset and dataset version #40

Closed Peyman-N closed 2 months ago

Peyman-N commented 3 months ago

The BIDS datasets have only one filed called Name, the instruction for this field is following :

Name of the dataset.

But in openMINDS we have two fields that can be filled by this information shortName and fullName. For the moment bids2openminds use this information to fill shortName dataset version and fullName in dataset.

@apdavison suggested following :

Why does the DSV have only "shortName" and the DS only "fullName"? I think it would be better to fill both fields for both the DSV and the DS.

I completely agree with him. @lzehl What are your thoughts on this?

lzehl commented 3 months ago

@Peyman-N @apdavison it is important to not mix up EBRAINS practices which openMINDS specs.

If I create DS / DSV outside of EBRAINS I would strongly suggest to always identify all information. Inheritance rules just identify a logic for systems that they can apply if information is not filled out. How this is done is system dependent. I would prefer the EBRAINS KG to actually do a autofill for inherited information (not leaving it empty and just applying the logic in display)

So: please specify all fields in DS and DSV.