Zap timer activates box erroneously from standby

[olwaldi]

Seit einigen OpenATV-Versionen wird der SAT-Receiver fälschlicherweise aus dem Standby geweckt, wenn ein Umschalttimer gesetzt ist. Richtigerweise soll ein Umschalttimer im Standby ignoriert werden.

Dieses fehlerhafte Verhalten tritt z.B. in allen 7.2-Versionen von OpenATV (bis inkl, Image vom 11.2.2023) auf.

-> Translated:

Since some OpenATV versions the SAT receiver is wrongly woken up from standby if a zap timer is set. Correctly a zap timer in standby should be ignored.

This erroneous behavior occurs e.g. in all 7.2 versions of OpenATV (up to incl, image from 11.2.2023).

[Papi2000-new]

Scenario:

• Start channel (also from standby) is set
• Switchover timer is set
• Box is in standby (or in deep) The switching timer was regarded by the user as an "alarm clock" because they wanted to watch a certain program but were doing something else until then. Then the box should wake up normally, turn on the previously seen (or start station - because of the time base) and switch to the desired station at the switching timer time. Furthermore, if necessary (HDMI-CEC settings set correctly), the AVR and TV should also be woken up. This is already explicitly taken into account in the HDMI-CEC settings. A switching timer has always woken up the boxes in the oATV. Because of a bug in the Standby.py (start-to-standby did not call the wanted channel - fixed on 10/02/23), only a few people had probably noticed this before. To switch to a wanted channel, the box must be in the power on state. If you don't wan your box to be not waken up, don't set a timer, that needs that state.

[jbleyel]

We can think about an extra setting to change the default behavior.

[olwaldi]

That would be nice. But it's not an urgent requirement.

BTW, what is the preferred language within GIT here?

[Papi2000-new]

Because of international contributers, its good to use english.

[IanSav]

English would be preferred by me. I only speak English. ;)

[jbleyel]

What about this? Change the last viewed channel If the zap fires and standby is active.

[olwaldi]

That wouldn't solve my "problem". In my usecase I've set a zap timer once a week to watch a special TVshow IF I'm at home viewing something differnt. But if I'm not at home (and my receiver is in standby) it shouldn't switch on.Thus probabely the only solution might be an additional attribute for zap timers to enable/disable wakeup for each zap timer individually.Von meinem Huawei-Tablet gesendet-------- Originalnachricht --------Betreff: Re: [openatv/enigma2] Zap timer activates box erroneously from standby (Issue #2785)Von: jbleyel An: openatv/enigma2 Cc: olwaldi ,Author What about this? Change the last viewed channel If the zap fires and standby is active.

—Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.> [ { @.": "http://schema.org", @.": "EmailMessage", "potentialAction": { @.": "ViewAction", "target": "https://github.com/openatv/enigma2/issues/2785#issuecomment-2130741623", "url": "https://github.com/openatv/enigma2/issues/2785#issuecomment-2130741623", "name": "View Issue" }, "description": "View this Issue on GitHub", "publisher": { @.***": "Organization", "name": "GitHub", "url": "https://github.com" } } ]

[jbleyel]

There are 3 options for the zap if the box is in standby:

1. Zap and wake up ( as of today )
2. Zap but don't wake up
3. Do nothing

We can add an extra system setting which is for all zap timers and not individual.

Adding an extra timer setting for each timer individual is a massive change and will also break 3rd party tools and other plugins.

[olwaldi]

From my perspective the second option is fine (for my usecase) - zap but do not switch on. My enigma2 device typically is in standby (NOT deep standby) when the zap timer triggers. Since I've configured a startup channel I'd assume that this startup channel will be selected anyhow when I do a manual power on (from standby).

[jbleyel]

The startup channel is for deep standby or reboot. The last channel before standby will be used after standby and not the startup channel. Option 2. means that the zap timer channel will be the next channel on wake up from standby. Option 3. means that the zap timer will do nothing.

[olwaldi]

Thanks for the clarification. But that's also fine for me. My main concern is that a zap timer currently might switch on the enigma2 device if I'm not at home, and it would be nice to avoid that.Von meinem Huawei-Tablet gesendet