Display problems in (java?) desktop GUI applications

mbtaylor commented 10 months ago

I have experienced issues with the display of java GUI applications in a science platform desktop session.

The issues are intermittent, have happened over a long period, and are in some cases just cosmetic and in other cases more serious.

Miscellaneous observations:

I've seen problems in topcat and Aladin. I haven't seen problems in ds9, which leads me to believe this might be a java issue. I haven't really tried other desktop applications.
One cosmetic effect is scrambling of toolbar button icons, see e.g. the screenshot here (posted by @severingaudet)
A more serious effect is in plot windows in topcat - they display OK when first plotted, but subsequent user interaction (pan/zoom) doesn't work properly, e.g. moves the axes around but not the plotted points
In Aladin I've had all-sky imagery claim in the GUI that it is loaded, but not visible in the display
I noticed these issues first in 06/2021, and again now (11/2023). I haven't really played with the science platform in between.
Problems are intermittent - e.g. at the moment it's behaving nicely. I'm not sure, but I have the impression that problems are more common in Canadian daytime than the middle of the Canadian night, so this could be related to loading?
I had an idea in 2021 that fiddling with java2d system properties, e.g. -Dsun.java2d.xrender=false might fix it. But as long as it's not misbehaving consistently I can't test that.

mbtaylor commented 10 months ago

Here's a screenshot of a topcat plot misbehaving. shot1 It's not very revealing, but take my word for it there should be a sky full of points visible. I just ran topcat :skysim:1000000 from a topcat-terminal and hit the Sky Plot toolbar button. Plot comes up nicely, but when I try to drag it around using the mouse, the axes move but the plotted points go away. Note also a couple of missing toolbar icons and scrambled pixelmaps on a horizontal and a vertical divider in the plot window - those are not really a problem, but tend to accompany the plot problems.

brianmajor commented 10 months ago

I don’t think this is the issue (is OpenGL used?) but posting for the record : https://bbs.archlinux.org/viewtopic.php?id=269181

mbtaylor commented 10 months ago

I'm not using OpenGL explicitly; I haven't attempted to check whether Java uses it but I would think not (there's no 3d graphics going on here). And the symptoms don't look very similar. So probably that's not the same issue.

mbtaylor commented 10 months ago

And here's a shot of Aladin misbehaving: aladin Icons on the left and right are scrambled, and the sky display is blank. Interacting with the plot appears to work in that the zoom slider bottom right moves, but the sky display does not respond.

brianmajor commented 10 months ago

Another post that may provide insight: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/35852534/java-swing-applications-not-rendering-properly-with-vnc

brianmajor commented 4 months ago

Raising the priority on this as it is clear it is affecting all Java-based desktop-apps.

brianmajor commented 3 months ago

@ijiraq - You mentioned that you have an idea of what the issue may be. Could you please post the details so we can give it a try?

opencadc / science-platform

Display problems in (java?) desktop GUI applications #578