search

openconfig / gnpsi

Apache License 2.0
10 stars 2 forks source link

gnpsi port number #10

Open LimeHat opened 2 months ago

LimeHat commented 2 months ago

What port number should be used by gNPSI servers?

Is there a plan to request IANA allocation?

RazorBach commented 1 month ago

gNPSI uses port 4739

@kishanps @dplore for question about IANA allocation problem

LimeHat commented 1 month ago

4739 is allocated for IPFIX.

IMO it should not be reused for gNPSI, that sets a bad precedent.

dplore commented 1 month ago

So far we have been rejected by IANA for a port allocation and the basis that the server can run on the same gRPC tcp port hosting gnmi/gnoi/etc and that gnpsi is not sufficiently differentiated from ipfix/sflow.

We may appeal this decision in the future if additional data comes up to support the position that gnpsi deserves it's own port.

Until then, the choice of tcp port for gnsi should be configurable by the end user via /system/grpc-servers/grpc-server/config/port