dct:issued validation on opendata.swiss: don't publish datasets that are not yet released

opendata-swiss / dcat_ap_ch

Examples for geocat and DCAT data-catalogs are given here

6 stars 3 forks source link

dct:issued validation on opendata.swiss: don't publish datasets that are not yet released #171

Open sabinem opened 3 years ago

sabinem commented 3 years ago

Property: 'dct:issued' Class: ´dcat:Dataset' Implementation: in the implementation on opendata.swiss a dataset can be set to published despite the fact that the release date is in the future. Conformance: This is not conformant to DCAT-AP CH since the usage note on dct:issued says: "In a data portal, the dataset will only be publicly displayed if it has an issued date and if that date is not in the future." Proposal:

Remove this statement above from the usage note since DCAT-AP CH is a standard to describe metadata and no guidebook on when or how to publish that metadata.The decision on when to publish the dataset should be left to the data portal.

Juan-Juan-1 commented 3 years ago

... Another possibility would be just to forget about this usage note. Do we really need such a mechanism? What do data publishers think about it? Do they want to be able to set a date in the future?

AFoletti commented 3 years ago

A date in the future does in my opinion not make much sense. Moreover, with it I am sort of making a promise I am not sure I can maintain (because delays always happen). So no, no date in the future in my opinion. Better no value

Juan-Juan-1 commented 3 years ago

A date in the future does in my opinion not make much sense. Moreover, with it I am sort of making a promise I am not sure I can maintain (because delays always happen). So no, no date in the future in my opinion. Better no value

Thank you @AFoletti. I think you are pointing the core of the issue... I still think it's worth a discussion since I have the feeling other data providers were instead interested in communicating "I will publish this".

metaodi commented 5 months ago

I agree with the original proposal of @sabinem to remove the usage note. This is not up to the standard to decide. It's up to opendata.swiss to add such a mechanism if needed.