openenergymonitor / heatpumpmonitor.org

public list of heat pumps sharing performance data via emoncms
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
18 stars 2 forks source link

DHW #12

Closed glynhudson closed 2 months ago

glynhudson commented 1 year ago

It would be a good idea to record display which systems are doing DHW + CH and which systems are just doing CH. Eg Adams SCOP is very impressive but obviously needs to be caveated and can't be directly compared with a system that's doing CH + DHW

davidMbrooke commented 1 year ago

A few thoughts on how this might be implemented:

zarch1972 commented 1 year ago

Is this issue for adding the ability to monitor DHW runs separately from heating? Or do we need another issue starting? We'd spoken about using CT clamp around DHW pump to differentiate between heating and hot water generation.

emoncms then picking that up and being able to show COP for each of heating and DHW for those that can CT clamp the DHW times?

davidMbrooke commented 1 year ago

I'm treating this Issue as what we'd change in heatpumpmonitor.org to have that provide a summary-level view of which systems listed there are CH-only versus mixed DHW and CH (and then ideally some indication of how mixed each one is).

I agree with you Mick that it would be great to have some metrics that give us heat-to-CH versus heat-to-DHW and the ability to measure CoP for CH versus CoP for DHW. I presume that means changing the MyHeatpump app (as distinct from heatpumpmonitor.org) so would the better place for an issue on that subject by the 'app' repo https://github.com/emoncms/app/issues ?

(While that would probably be the strictly-correct thing to do, the distinction might be lost on most people, so maybe we keep all the issues together, in here?)

So, in summary:

MrTimbones commented 7 months ago

It would be a good idea to record display which systems are doing DHW + CH and which systems are just doing CH

A simple boolean indicator of Yes or No for DHW heating

The site already captures which systems do or do not have have DHW in the DHW control type field.

When we're able to do advanced filtering (#10) then it'll be possible to exclude systems without DHW, for example.

  • Whether there are complementary sources of DHW (e.g. solar thermal or solar PV divert)?
  • How many occupants are consuming DHW?
  • To what temperature is the stored DHW being heated?

This last item is captured in the system form, but the other two are not. Should we add them? Or is the form long enough?

Is this issue for adding the ability to monitor DHW runs separately from heating?

This is now provided directly by My Heatpump app, though HeatpumpMonitor doesn't aggregate this data yet -> #41