openfaas / python-flask-template

HTTP and Flask-based OpenFaaS templates for Python 3
MIT License
85 stars 86 forks source link

Support multipart/form-data and json #18

Open dschulten opened 5 years ago

dschulten commented 5 years ago

The python3-http templates use an Event abstraction which represents the incoming request. Currently the Event only holds the request.data as body, which is the body as byte array.

Suggestion: Leverage Flask's support for multipart/form-data, application/json (and x-www-form-urlencoded) by adding the following attributes to the Event object:

  1. request.files and request.form - they are needed for multipart/form-data requests. The request.files attribute is an ImmutableMultiDict of FileStorage (which is a file-ish ducktype) where every entry is a list of files. The request.form is an ImmutableMultiDict of strings which represent the textual multiparts which have no filename in their content-disposition (or the values of an x-www-form-urlencoded body). We already preserve ImmutableMultiDict in Event.query, so it seems straightforward to add files and form, too
  2. request.get_json() - it only gets filled when the request is of Content-Type: application/json
class Event:
    def __init__(self):
        self.body = request.get_data()
        self.json = request.get_json()
        self.form = request.form
        self.files = request.files
        self.headers = request.headers
        self.method = request.method
        self.query = request.args
        self.path = request.path

The format_body method also needs to be adjusted so that it uses Flask's support for file responses if the handler returns a file.

return send_file(fout, 'application/pdf')

This gives us the ability to upload files to such functions and download the function result (would also enable us to have uploads in the OpenFaaS Dashboard). Depending on Flask's implementation this also gives us support for large files.

I am preparing a PR for the python3-http template, and I could do likewise for the IRequest in the Java Template.

Please let me know if you approve of the general idea.

dschulten commented 5 years ago

I have prepared a branch for a possible PR: https://github.com/dschulten/python-flask-template/tree/multipart-form-data-support, with updated README.

Demo: https://github.com/dschulten/python-flask-template/tree/PyPDF2-merge, see https://github.com/dschulten/python-flask-template/blob/PyPDF2-merge/template/python3-http/function/handler.py

Documentation with sample request: https://github.com/dschulten/python-flask-template/tree/multipart-form-data-support#working-with-multipart-requests

Jeff-Lowrey commented 4 years ago

@dschulten Hi - this is great! I haven't look at it yet, but it is something that I needed for one of my functions. . I've done some hackery, but a clean and reusable solution is better.

mrhatbirb commented 3 years ago

is there a reason why this was not merged? I feel like the edit is pretty straightforward - just adding some properties to the Event class. Came here to send a PR for it, but seeing that the issue is two years old makes me think that it will be ignored.