Publish OpenFisca data to data.gouv.fr ? - Githubissues

openfisca / tutorial

OpenFisca Tutorial Notebooks

http://mybinder.org/repo/openfisca/tutorial

GNU Affero General Public License v3.0

13 stars 6 forks source link

Publish OpenFisca data to data.gouv.fr ? #26

Closed sandcha closed 6 years ago

sandcha commented 6 years ago

Relates to openfisca/openfisca-france#888

Définition of done : To-do liste actionable pour la publication, ou pas.

Anna-Livia commented 6 years ago

Les situations sont issues du [livret du pouvoir d'achat]()
elles se trouvent ici

bonjourmauko commented 6 years ago

For now, and beyond the particular uses of OpenFisca by its contributors, it seems there are some main positioning paths (that are not exclusive):

As a tool for OpenGovernment (and specially for international development)
As a tool for government-as-a-platform (through the API)
As a service (offering OpenFisca by itself)
As a data-driven policy tool (reforms evaluation)

It looks like is in the latter where the publication of aggregated data, test cases and samples could be more appropriate and useful, as it would be the case of the analysis of impact of reforms.

That being said, I'm not sure what would be a condition for generated data to be published and considered as open data. Representativeness ? Fit for purpose ?

Thanks for your thoughts @benjello and @pachevalier

bonjourmauko commented 6 years ago

@MattiSG dixit ;

La première fois que j'avais évoqué la possibilité de faire des datasets à partir des paramètres, ça datait de décembre 2014 (auprès d'Emmanuel). J'en avais parlé à nouveau l'an dernier à data.gouv.fr, il n'y avait pas de ressources dispo pour collaborer, mais un début d'intérêt.

bonjourmauko commented 6 years ago

To continue the discussion, some clues:

Parameters and variables (see openfisca/openfisca-france#905)
Situations (https://github.com/edarin/population_simulator)

For the latter, question is whether we should create those samples ourselves or push for the INSEE to do it.

cc @benjello @pachevalier

bonjourmauko commented 6 years ago

We'll probably work on this this Friday in the context of Fridaylabs at Etalab

benjello commented 6 years ago

Variables are a choice of implementation. Parameters can be useful but should be organized to be usable. Somehow the legislation explorer with an export button would be better than a dump. Situations: I do not see the usefulness of sharing them.

bonjourmauko commented 6 years ago

Parameters can be useful but should be organized to be usable

We'll get there soon.

Situations: I do not see the usefulness of sharing them.

I see a collection of hypothetical data as a good starting kit, not sure anymore about synthetical data though.

bonjourmauko commented 6 years ago

So results of the investigation :

Parameters and variables (see openfisca/openfisca-france#905)
Hypothetical data on https://data.gouv.fr

Note: build a library of hypothetical data on https://data.gouv.fr "opportunistically"