Req without Shall

[KathiSchleidt]

-046 Interface Observation
The requirement in this section does not contain the verbal form "shall". Instead, it is written as statement of fact. Please verify that this is correct.

[KathiSchleidt]

-059 Set of common characteristics used for describing an Observation or a collection of Observations.
This section of text is labelled "requirement" but it does not contain the verbal form "shall". Please review.

[KathiSchleidt]

-091 A StatisticalSample is a statistical subset of a feature-of-interest, defined for the purpose of creating Observation(s). This text is marked as a requirement, but the verbal form "shall" is not used. Please check.

[KathiSchleidt]

-098 A location identified by its name, address, spatial geometry or a combination of any of these three. This text is marked as a requirement, but the verbal form "shall" is not used. Please check.

[KathiSchleidt]

-046 8.2.2 Interface Observation An observation is an act carried out by an Observer to determine the value of an ObservableProperty of an object (featureOfInterest) by using an ObservingProcedure; the value is provided as the result**.

How about rephrasing An Observation shall be an act...

While there isn't a comment, there are other reqs without a shall, e.g. 8.3.2 Interface ObservableProperty A quality (property, characteristic) of the feature-of-interest that can be observed.

Based on the logic above, this should be modified to read: An ObservableProperty shall be a quality ...

[KathiSchleidt]

Also applies to:

• 8.4.2 Interface Procedure: A description of steps performed.
• 8.5.2 Interface ObservingProcedure: The description of steps performed in order to determine the value of an observableProperty by an Observer.
• 8.6.2 Interface Observer: An identifiable entity that can generate Observations pertaining to an observableProperty by implementing an ObservingProcedure.
• 8.7.2 Interface Host: A grouping of Observers for a specific reason.
• 8.8.2 Interface Deployment: Information on the assignment of an Observer to a Host.
• 9.2.2 Feature type AbstractObservationCharacteristics: Set of common characteristics used for describing an Observation or a collection of Observations.
• 10.4.2 Feature type ObservationCollection: A collection of similar Observations
• 10.5.2 Feature type ObservingCapability: Information on Observation(s) that could potentially be provided.
• 11.2.2 Interface Sample: A Sample is an object that is representative of a concept, real-world object or phenomenon.
• 11.3.2 Interface Sampling: Sampling is an act applying a SamplingProcedure to create or transform one or more Sample(s).
• 11.4.2 Interface Sampler: A Sampler is a device or entity (including humans) that is used by, or implements, a SamplingProcedure to create or transform one or more Sample(s).
• 11.5.2 Interface PreparationStep: A PreparationStep is an individual step pertaining to a PreparationProcedure.
• 11.6.2 Interface PreparationProcedure: The description of preparation steps performed on a Sample.
• 11.7.2 Interface SamplingProcedure: The description of steps performed by a Sampler in order to extract a Sample from its sampledFeature in the frame of a Sampling.
• 13.3.2 Feature type SpatialSample: A SpatialSample is a geospatial Sample.
• 13.4.2 Feature type MaterialSample: A MaterialSample is a physical, tangible Sample.
• 13.5.2 Feature type StatisticalSample: A StatisticalSample is a statistical subset of a feature-of-interest, defined for the purpose of creating Observation(s).
• 13.11.2 Feature type SampleCollection: A collection of Samples.
• 13.12.2 Data type PhysicalDimension: A dataType for the provision of various size quantities.
• 13.13.2 Data type NamedLocation: A location identified by its name, address, spatial geometry or a combination of any of these three.
• 13.14.2 Data type StatisticalClassification: A dataType for the provision of information on statistical classifications.

Modify all described above

[KathiSchleidt]

An Observation is shall be defined as: blablabla

use pattern for all

[sgrellet]

had to fix twice a weird structure '115orrespo' in place of dataType... and found 2 other occurences of that pattern in section C.3. Don't know how they got in the doc. Hopefully is ok now.