openHAB 1 addon compatibility overview with openHAB 3

Hilbrand commented 4 years ago

This issue contains an overview of all openHAB 1 add-ons and how/if there is an openHAB 3 version.

Disclaimer: This list is not a planning or to do list. It just gives an overview of the status of migrations or known other new versions bindings. If you want to know if a binding will be available in openHAB 3 and it's not mentioned on the list ask on the openHAB forum. Use the comments to report new or changed entries to the list.

There are 3 tables. The first table contains the openHAB 1 add-ons with no (official) openHAB 3 version, but have been voted on in the poll or are being worked on. The table contains the links to the work-in-progress if known. The second table is with unsupported openHAB 1 bindings that have not be voted on. These bindings have potential very few users and therefor the chance someone will migrate it to openHAB 3 is very low. The third table is with openHAB 1 add-ons that have a known openHAB 3 replacement. When an openHAB 1 binding from the first 2 tables has been migrated it's moved to third table.

In the lists the persistence add-ons are not included because separate work has been done: PR #5275.

The column supported in the table means if the add-on was officially supported in openHAB 2. This means it's included in the feature file and known to work with openHAB 2 and show up in PaperUI when legacy mode is activated. If not supported it still might work, but it needs to be installed manually.

The poll results are from the (closed) poll from the openHAB forum: poll-which-oh1-x-addons-do-you-use. Some add-ons have no poll results because those have an openHAB 2 variant and were not in the poll.

The column Java LOC is the number of Lines of Code of the add-on. This can give an indication on the complexity of the binding.

The column Feature Compatible in the last table mentions if the openHAB 3 bindings lacks some features that where part of the openHAB 1 binding.

This information is compiled to have an overview of the differences and compatibility of different openHAB add-on versions. If something is missing or changed please comment or update this list. If you have or use an openHAB 3 binding but it doesn't have the same features as the openHAB 1 version please also report.

Add-ons to Migrate

Add-on	OH3 Add-on	Supported in OH2	Poll results	Java LOC	Notes
Actions	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
mios	~PR #2283~	supported	7	183	PR closed
openwebif		unsupported	2	479
pebble		supported	4	215
tinkerforge	Issue #85	unsupported	1	129
weather		unsupported	9	73
Bindings	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
asterisk		unsupported	5	373
cardio2e		supported	1	6540
cups	yes?	unsupported	1	225	Renamed as ipp? PR #164
davis		unsupported	0	2307
ddwrt		unsupported	1	456
dmx.artnet	?	unsupported	1	62
dmx.lib485	?	unsupported	0	51
dmx.ola	?	unsupported		69
ebus		supported	1	2876
fatekplc		supported	1	1437	Forum topic 113085
fht		unsupported	2	745
freeswitch		supported	0	637
fritzaha		unsupported	1	1257
fs20		supported	2	343	Depends on cul transport. Supported via RFXCOM binding?
garadget		supported	4	752	Can be replaced by MQTT
gc100ir		supported	0	1079
heatmiser		supported	0	1053
horizon		supported	1	371
intertechno	Supported via RFXCOM binding?	supported	1	519	Supported via RFXCOM binding?
isy	Branch isy-binding-new	unsupported	3	1078	No PR, but this branch seems to contain work on this binding
jointspace		supported	2	445
k8055		supported	0	352
koubachi		supported	0	656	Koubachi service no longer exists. Will not be ported.
lightwaverf		unsupported	1	3717	Forum topic 92264
maxcul/transport.cul	PR #9732	supported	4/1	2396 /1299	Forum topic 112897
mios	~PR #2283~	supported	7	1923	PR is named vera. Mios seems to be rebranded to vera? PR closed
mochadx10		supported	1	828
mystromecopower	~PR #2756~	supported	1	639	PR Closed
openenergymonitor		supported	5	791
openpaths		unsupported	1	507
owserver		supported	3	424
panasonictv	PR #11559	supported	8	214
piface		supported	0	634
plex	PR #12135	supported	27	1804	Issue #4949, Forum topic 111487, Branch: plex
samsungac		supported	0	1145
sapp		supported	0	1942
smarthomatic		unsupported	1	2162
sonance		supported	0	444
stiebelheatpump	~PR #3483~	unsupported	0	3228	PR Closed
swegonventilation		supported	1	804
tcp		supported	25	3528
tinkerforge	OH2 repo theoweiss	unsupported	4	91952	No PR, See also: ThinkerForge Forum/(#85).
ucprelayboard		supported	0	543
wago	Supported via the modbus binding	unsupported	0	626	Supported via the modbus binding
weather		supported	31	3337
withings	~PR #9154~	unsupported	2	783	PR Closed
IO	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
caldav		supported	24	181	See the icalendar binding
gcal		supported	12	932
harmonyhub		unsupported	11	591
multimedia.tts .freetts		unsupported	1	54
multimedia.tts .speechdispatcher		unsupported	0	134
transport.xpl		unsupported	1	73	This protocol is dead. Will not be ported.

Unused Add-ons

This is the table with all openHAB 1 add-ons that have no openHAB 3 replacement, are not part of legacy and had zero votes. It's uncertain if these bindings are still used. If they are used they belong in the table above.

Add-on	OH3 Add-on	Supported in OH2	Poll results	Java LOC	Notes
Actions	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
ciscospark		unsupported	0	189
xpl		unsupported	0	118
Bindings	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
akm868		unsupported	0	367
configadmin		unsupported	0	245
diyonxbee		unsupported	0	519
ehealth		unsupported	0	432
em		unsupported	0	316	No readme
hms		unsupported	0	198
mcp3424		unsupported	0	342
octoller		unsupported	0	243
panstamp		unsupported	0	816
plcbus		unsupported	0	932
powerdoglocalapi		unsupported	0	532
primare		unsupported	0	1774
rpircswitch		unsupported	0	336
s300th		unsupported	0	305
sallegra		unsupported	0	377
wr3223	Code wr32243	unsupported	0	1776	frami/org.openhab.binding.wr3223
xpl		unsupported	0	267	This protocol is dead. Will not be ported.
zibase		unsupported	0	613

Migrated Add-ons

This is the table with all openHAB 1 add-ons that have an official openHAB 3 version.

Add-on	OH3 Add-on	Feature Compatible	Poll results	Java LOC	Notes
Actions	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
astro	yes		34	131
dscalarm	yes		4	111
ecobee	~PR #6823~		8	293
harmonyhub	yes		15	126
homematic	yes		4	82
mail	yes			187
mqtt	yes			112
prowl	~PR #10967~		2	129	Forum topic 111478
pushbullet	yes			466
pushsafer	~PR #10790~		1	184
satel	yes			187
squeezebox	yes		8	434
telegram	~PR #5677~		47	369
twitter	~PR #10241~		2	319
xbmc	yes		10	72	Replaced by Kodi Binding
xmpp	yes		3	443
Bindings	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
alarmdecoder	~PR #7189~		3	890
anel	yes		3	907
astro	yes			2563
autelis	yes		0	300
bticino	~PR #6213~	no	0	2521	Name: openwebnet, Misses Temperature Control and CEN commands
benqprojector	~PR #10341~		1	605
bluetooth	yes		5	398
caldav-command	~PR #6453~	no	23	469	Implemented as iCal, which offers similar features, but read-only
caldav-personal	~PR #6453~	no	32	606
comfoair	~PR #7052~	yes	9	3100
cups	yes?		1	377	Renamed as ipp? PR #164
daikin	yes		1	1553
denon	yes		9	5233
digitalstrom	yes		0	1826
dmx	yes			3368
dscalarm	yes		3	1581
dsmr	yes			2121
ecobee	~PR #6823~		9	6181
ecotouch	~PR #10010~	supported	2	1308
ekey	~PR #10996~		0	374
energenie	~PR #6461~		2	482
enigma2	~PR #7514~		3	520
enphaseenergy	~PR #9883~		2	438	Renamed enphase Forum topic #44449
enocean	yes			509
epsonprojector	~PR #9021~		5	1853
exec	yes	no		745
freebox	yes		0	625
fritzboxtr064	~PR #8523~		52	1870
gpio (io)	~PR #1334~		18	494 (795)
harmonyhub	yes		14	786
hdanywhere	yes		0	360
homematic	yes			450
http	~PR #8521~		95	995
hue	yes		18	4651
iec6205621meter	yes		1	732	smartmeter binding
ihc	yes			878
insteonhub			1	1246	Replaced by OH1 insteonPLM
insteonplm	~PR #6911~		13	6637	New binding is called insteon. PR merged
ipx800	~PR #5457~		1	1397	Renamed to GCE
irtrans	yes			2724
km200	yes		2	855
knx	yes			2272
lcn	~PR #7509~		1	6384
lgtv	yes	no	7	3131	LGWebOs and LG Serial OH3 bindings use a different protocol, so might not be compatible
mailcontrol	yes		3	1936
maxcube	yes		2	634
mcp23017	yes		0	2853
milight	yes			342
modbus	yes			892
mpd	~PR #7870~		2	869
mqtt	yes	no		12830
mqttitude	yes			1083
myq	~PR #9347~		7	757	Fullname is ChamberlainMyQ
neohub	~PR #5952~		0	467
nest	yes			415
netatmo	yes			2282
networkhealth	yes			3053
networkupstools	~PR #6192~		26	244
nibeheatpump	yes			190
nikobus	~PR #6021~		9	1109
novelanheatpump	~PR #9669~		1	1060	Renamed to luktronik Forum topic 70743
ntp	yes		12	1929
oceanic	yes		0	179
omnilink	~PR #8922~		2	2293
onewire	yes			820
onkyo	yes	no		1769	OH3 binding doesn’t support serial connection like in OH1 binding
opensprinkler	yes		5	1515
pilight	~PR #9744~		2	1161
pioneeravr	yes		2	277
plclogo	yes		1	1266
plugwise	yes			2189
powermax	yes			3553
pulseaudio	yes		2	3829
pushover	~PR #8586~		30	669
rfxcom	yes		4	1281
rme	yes		0	8382
rwesmarthome	yes			448
sagercaster	~PR #4754~		0	5542
samsungtv	yes		13	2094
satel	yes			847
serial	~PR #8851~		24	636
snmp	yes		21	2979
sonos	yes		7	668
souliss	~PR #11083~		1	2729
squeezebox	yes		8	4150
squeezeserver	yes		0	1168	Supported by squeezebox
systeminfo	yes			393
tacmi	~PR #7768~		1	469
tellstick	yes			776
tivo	~PR #9302~		1	120
upb	~PR #6742~		0	744
urtsi	yes			1658
vdr	~PR #9947~		1	620	Issue #9931
velux	~PR #2531~		9	8494
wemo	yes		4	480
wol	~PR #8336~		42	147	Part of network binding
xbmc	yes		11	1998	Replaced by Kodi Binding
yamahareceiver	yes		5	577
zwave	yes			18948
IO	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
multimedia.tts.googletts	yes		3	229
multimedia.tts.macintalk	yes		0	35
multimedia.tts.marytts	yes		2	70
transport.mqtt	yes		46	604
Other	=====	=====	=====	=====	=====
expire	~PR openhab/openhab-core/pull/1803~		95	239	Added as core framework feature

Hilbrand commented 3 years ago

@delid4ve the binding is unsupported as mentioned above, and explained what it means that its unsupported.

delid4ve commented 3 years ago

@delid4ve the binding is unsupported as mentioned above, and explained what it means that its unsupported.

Apologies, just remember seeing it in the Ui in 2.something when I first started my journey so didn’t even realise it had actually been marked as unsupported

frami commented 3 years ago

There is a migrated version of the wr3223 binding. It is in a separate repository https://github.com/frami/org.openhab.binding.wr3223 Is it possible to add a link in the notes of the migration list? The reason for the separate repository is, for more flexibility and I think there are not so many users which using this binding.

mrudowicz commented 3 years ago

No List has no Addon FATEK_PLC is there any chance that it will be in OpenHab3

Hilbrand commented 3 years ago

@mrudowicz based on the current information on this list: No. The openHAB forum is a better place to ask this question.

Flole998 commented 3 years ago

Actually: Yes there is a chance, if you develop the binding and it follows all the guidelines then it will most likely make it in. Chances are actually pretty high that it will make it in. ;)

slawekjaranowski commented 3 years ago

Hi @mrudowicz I'm author of FatekPLC binding, I thinking about migrate it. Lets start topic on forum to track progress.

mrudowicz commented 3 years ago

Hi @mrudowicz I'm author of FatekPLC binding, I thinking about migrate it. Lets start topic on forum to track progress.

Super Mam nadzieje ze uda Ci sięszybko ogarnac dodatek do v3. sporo ludzi ma Fateka :)

mrudowicz commented 3 years ago

https://community.openhab.org/t/fatek-plc-migration-to-openhab-v3/113085?u=mrudowicz

udo1toni commented 3 years ago

For your information, Matthias Klocke wrote a vdr2 binding. See https://community.openhab.org/t/vdr-binding/10839/24 for details.

openhab-bot commented 3 years ago

This issue has been mentioned on openHAB Community. There might be relevant details there:

https://community.openhab.org/t/collection-of-binding-requests/113854/2

udo1toni commented 3 years ago

Further details to vdr2/vdr3 Binding:

https://github.com/openhab/openhab-addons/issues/9931

delid4ve commented 3 years ago

LightwaveRF will shortly be supported in 2.5x and 3.x. I'm currently adding in gen1 local support (openhab-v1 addon - although a new api) to my working gen2 (cloud) binding. Should be ready to submit in a couple of weeks. Thread can be monitored here:

https://community.openhab.org/t/lightwaverf-new-lightwaverf-binding/92264

openhab-bot commented 3 years ago

This issue has been mentioned on openHAB Community. There might be relevant details there:

https://community.openhab.org/t/oh2-oh3-older-bindings-no-longer-supported/116084/7

FeKn commented 3 years ago

Regarding 'davis' binding: Is it possible to move the binding davis from Unused Add-ons to Add-ons to Migrate?

Meteostick is not an alternative because it requires a special hardware dongle and is not able to connect to a Davis data logger directly via RS-232 or USB.

lucacalcaterra commented 3 years ago

why souliss pr 10034 result as closed ?

Flole998 commented 3 years ago

Because it used to refer to PR #4945 which was closed and most likely when the new PR was added it was simply forgotten to remove that.

lucacalcaterra commented 3 years ago

Because it used to refer to PR #4945 which was closed and most likely when the new PR was added it was simply forgotten to remove that.

Ok, i must rebase due to errors with git commands. So now it's ready to continue approval flow. Thanks !

hmerk commented 3 years ago

Added new ekey binding contribution (PR #10996) to the list in the first post.

mlobstein commented 3 years ago

benqprojector can be moved to the migrated list

andrewfg commented 2 years ago

@Hilbrand many thanks for the issue, and the work behind it. On a point of order, I am not sure that the table Migrated Add-ons: table with all add-ons that have an official openHAB 3 version is strictly necessary. (??) As the list of OH 3 addons is self evident.

Hilbrand commented 2 years ago

@andrewfg The migrated list contains only add-ons that were available as openHAB 1 add-on. Initially it was to track if a migrated add-on was feature compatible with the then openHAB 2 add-on. Later, when other openHAB 1 add-ons were migrated and moved to the list, the original PR link was added. That way people could easily track back where the migrated add-on came from or it contains additional background information related that might be relevant for the migrated add-on with regards to the original openHAB 1 add-on. (P.s. I've added 'openHAB 1' to the title of the table to make it more clear this is a list of openHAB 1 add-ons).

openhab-bot commented 1 year ago

This issue has been mentioned on openHAB Community. There might be relevant details there:

https://community.openhab.org/t/openhab-3-fs20-binding/146285/3

openhab-bot commented 10 months ago

This issue has been mentioned on openHAB Community. There might be relevant details there:

https://community.openhab.org/t/is-the-max-system-still-usable-in-2023/150615/3

lsiepel commented 9 months ago

As openHAB 1 and later on openhab 2 with the compatibility layer is long time history, i propose to close this issue. If there are still addons not migrated, i suppose there is no need for it or no one is willing to do so.

openhab / openhab-addons