Editorial Issues in Appendix E.2 and E.3

[TakahikoKawasaki]

Editorial issues found in the working group draft built on December 22, 2023, published at https://openid.github.io/OpenID4VCI/openid-4-verifiable-credential-issuance-wg-draft.html

E.2.2. Credential Issuer Metadata, the example JSON

• The Japanese translations for display[1].name (在籍証明書) and display[1].logo.alt_text (大学のロゴ) are inappropriate. They mean "Certificate of Enrollment" and "Logo of University", respectively.

E.3.2. Credential Issuer Metadata, the 1st paragraph

• credentials_supported -> credential_configurations_supported

E.3.2. Credential Issuer Metadata, the example JSON

• credentials_supported -> credential_configurations_supported

E.3.3. Authorization Details

• vct should not be required because credential_configuration_id is sufficient. (Like doctype is no longer required in the case of mso_mdoc.)
• The example JSON should contain credential_configuration_id and should not contain format and vct.

[TakahikoKawasaki]

E.3.2. Credential Issuer Metadata, the example JSON

• It's better to change last_name to family_name to align with 5.1. Standard Claims of OIDC Core 1.0.
• It might be worth considering to change is_over_18, is_over_21, is_over_65 to age_over_18, age_over_21, age_over_65, respectively, to align with "7.2.5 Age attestation: nearest "true" attestation above request" of "ISO/IEC 18013-5:2021".

Others

There are two proof_types_supported in the draft. They should be changed to proof_types.

[selfissued]

Taka is of course right. This especially matters in cultures like Korea, where the first name pronounced is the family name. We should do this before the first Implementer's Draft.

[jogu]

I believe @selfissued fixed the two issues in E.3.2 (now moved to A.3.2 in the latest version of the spec).

https://github.com/openid/OpenID4VCI/pull/216 will fix the Japanese text.

The remaining issue to be resolved is the one in E.3.3 (now A.3.3):

vct should not be required because credential_configuration_id is sufficient. (Like doctype is no longer required in the case of mso_mdoc.)

[Sakurann]

per discussion in #217,

vct should not be required because credential_configuration_id is sufficient. (Like doctype is no longer required in the case of mso_mdoc.) The example JSON should contain credential_configuration_id and should not contain format and vct.

is now valid, so i think we can close this issue.

[jogu]

I agree, any fix for #217 will fix the remaining issue Taka raised. We can just close now right?