search

openid / sharedsignals

OpenID Shared Signals Working Group Repository
45 stars 11 forks source link

If a transmitter supports CAEP events, should the delivery method be CAEP specific? #65

Closed appsdesh closed 1 year ago

appsdesh commented 1 year ago

I noticed that delivery methods are limited to

If a transmitter only supports CAEP events, do you suggest it uses risc specific delivery-methods, or is ok to support the following?

Both [DELIVERYPOLL] and [DELIVERYPUSH] don't provide guidance.

independentid commented 1 year ago

You may be confusing event types (expressed as SETs) with the transfer method protocols (SET Push and Poll Transfer).  AFAIK there is no protocol specific to caep. RFC8935 (SET Push),8936 (SET Poll) are standard transfer mechanisms for any SET. SSF just defines stream configuration management (eg what are the endpoints that 8935/8936 use) and the event types that will be transmitted. Thus limiting the event types to CAEP doesn’t affect the delivery method. Phil

appsdesh commented 1 year ago

Thanks, my question was more on the namespaces used in RFC8935 (SET Push),8936 (SET Poll) delivery-method semantics. It refers to risc.

But from your explanation, it appears that the transfer mechanisms namespace is standard and it would not reflect which profiles (risc/caep) are used in the transfer.

FragLegs commented 1 year ago

@appsdesh I agree that it is confusing. We already have a PR up to fix it. It is approved and just waiting on @timcappalli to merge it. https://github.com/openid/sharedsignals/pull/49

independentid commented 1 year ago

Great!PhilOn Jun 1, 2023, at 5:22 AM, FragLegs @.***> wrote: @appsdesh I agree that it is confusing. We already have a PR up to fix it. It is approved and just waiting on @timcappalli to merge it. #49

—Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

appsdesh commented 1 year ago

Thank you @FragLegs @independentid 👍