openjournals / brief-ideas

The Journal of Brief Ideas
http://beta.briefideas.org
MIT License
93 stars 10 forks source link

Hello #169

Closed PerigGouanvic closed 5 years ago

PerigGouanvic commented 5 years ago

I would like to cancel a submission. How should i proceed?

physicsdavid commented 5 years ago

I can just reject it now but I'd be interested to know the reason for cancelling it. (I don't need specifics, but just out of curiosity is it because you don't think the idea is solid, you've found somebody else has had it, you're planning on trying to publish it elsewhere, etc.)

Thanks, David

PerigGouanvic commented 5 years ago

Somebody else had a very similar idea (but not in the JBI). I could rewrite entirely my idea to emphasize some aspects that are distinctive (I came to the idea through a different route), but I'll give myself some time to avoid doing other mistakes.

Thanks

physicsdavid commented 5 years ago

Thanks for the extra info - it always helps to hear that sort of thing. We encourage incremental ideas so if you have something that goes beyond the other work and builds on it in some way, then please submit it (with a reference to the other work). Thanks!