openjournals / jose-old

The Journal of Open Source Education (JOSE) is an educator-friendly journal for publishing computational learning modules & educational software.
http://jose.theoj.org
MIT License
94 stars 10 forks source link

suggests learning objectives as statement of need in paper.md requirements #9

Closed katyhuff closed 6 years ago

katyhuff commented 6 years ago

One minor thought : I wonder if guiding the authors toward using learning outcomes to describe the "need" for the learning module would be helpful (to both authors and reviewers). Although we stop short of explicitly requiring learning objectives in the modules, requesting a summary in the form of learning outcomes seems to me like the most straightforward and universal way to describe "need" for a module.

labarba commented 6 years ago

I disagree with this edit. The need for a learning module is one thing; the learning outcomes quite another. The statement of need is where the authors may justify creating a module on a subject where another already exists. They could say that they approach a subject differently, they update to modern contexts, or whatever. They could say that there is a need because of a new program, or a conference tutorial they gave, or another informal-learning scenario.

On the other hand, I'm wary on the buzzword quality of learning outcomes. It's overused and misused. Nobody can guarantee an outcome—despite what the booming assessment industry wants us to believe—because learners bring their whole history to the learning.

katyhuff commented 6 years ago

ok