openlibhums / janeway

A web-based platform for publishing journals, preprints, conference proceedings, and books
https://janeway.systems/
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
177 stars 65 forks source link

Inconsistency of information concerning Reviewed Article as viewed by the Author #774

Closed ccaadeh closed 5 years ago

ccaadeh commented 5 years ago

https://demojournal.janeway.systems/review/article/611/review/132/view/ Logged in with a privileged account i.e. as an Editor. I can see the article has been reviewed and rejected, so the review task is marked as having been completed. screenshot 80

However, if I login as the author, it looks as if no review has taken place as the 'Date Completed' is blank: screenshot 81 screenshot 82

This might be because all the options are set to hide the info from the author. However, even if I change the settings to allow some visibility . . . and click on the 'Update Individual View Option' . . .

screenshot 83](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/44443205/51467801-4ea74c00-1d65-11e9-91a0-11652474305c.png)

the author still can't see that the review has been completed, and it states that access has not been granted (even after refreshing the session) . . .

screenshot 85

Back again as the editor, if I change back to 'Hide from Author' but also tick the 'Allow Author to View' box . . .

screenshot 86

{I think the functionality of the various show/hide options is not clear}

From the Author's view the 'Date completed' field is still blank but I can now see the 'View Review' button . . .

screenshot 87

and eventually I can see the review and the date the task was completed:

screenshot 88

ajrbyers commented 5 years ago

I suspect this bug is much simpler than it appears. On the author page date_completed is probably missing or mis-spelled.

ajrbyers commented 5 years ago

Adding this to Trello, please ignore.

ajrbyers commented 5 years ago

Adding this to Trello, please ignore.