search

opennewzealand / linz2osm

Some tools for helping move LINZ data into OpenStreetMap
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/LINZ
GNU General Public License v3.0
22 stars 2 forks source link

fields.within_linz_layer for island_poly misses some #116

Open HamishB opened 11 years ago

HamishB commented 11 years ago

Hi,

Steve added a within_linz_layer DB column for the island_poly layer, to convert from natural=coastline to natural=land when the island falls within a lake, pond, etc. and is not coastal.

In workslice 1209 you'll see that islands within river_poly have not been tagged. The stats page shows counts somewhat lower than I'd expect for the number of islands within lakes, rivers, etc for the mainland -- many of them missed?

thanks, Hamish

stephend commented 11 years ago

Maybe, I found with ponds that a lot of the pond_poly polygons had island-shaped holes in them, so the islands weren't technically "within" the polygon in a geometric sense. Past-me emailed out that it only seemed to apply to ponds, but maybe past-me was wrong. Or it could be something else...

HamishB commented 11 years ago

I see an interesting case with workslice 1226, some of the islands in Havelock River are =land, others right next to them =coastline.