search

openreview / openreview-py

Official Python client library for the OpenReview API
https://openreview-py.readthedocs.io/en/latest/
MIT License
134 stars 18 forks source link

Fix/ Camera Ready Revisions: add pub chairs as readers of authors and authorids #2193

Closed celestemartinez closed 3 weeks ago

celestemartinez commented 3 weeks ago

Fixes #2177

If the venue has publication chairs, then add them as readers of the authors and authorids fields in revision invitations when the submission revision stage is enabled for accepted papers only.

The issue this still has is that if author names are released after creating camera ready invitations, the invitations will still have readers for authors and authorids, and posting a camera ready revision will once again hide the author names from the public; this happened in ICML. I am not sure how to fix this, unless after running the post decision and releasing author names to the public, we check if there is a revision stage active and re-run it?

celestemartinez commented 3 weeks ago

@melisabok any ideas on how to fix the issue mentioned above, where camera ready revisions are created (which contain readers on the author fields) and then author identities are released to the public)?

melisabok commented 3 weeks ago

unless after running the post decision and releasing author names to the public, we check if there is a revision stage active and re-run it?

Yes, I think we should re-run the stage in the post decision implementation.