openreview / openreview-web

The official web interface for OpenReview.net
https://openreview.net
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
13 stars 2 forks source link

Edge browser: filter assignments by active papers #1600

Open celestemartinez opened 1 year ago

celestemartinez commented 1 year ago

The total number of assignments for a user in the edge browser includes withdrawn papers. These assignment edges still exist because we don't remove them when a paper is withdrawn, but they should not be counted as assignments since the papers are not active.

How to reproduce:

melisabok commented 1 year ago

@xkopenreview is there a chance we can update the counter when the second column is shown.

I know it is difficult to have an API call to get the edge count filtering out the papers that are not active, so my idea is that when the first column is loaded, it shows the 4 assignments but when you click on the user the next column will load all the papers and because they don't exists the counter is updated to 0.

Another option is to do what Celeste suggests: when loading all the papers and saving the counters in the global map, filter out the edges that are not active.

Third option: remove the edges when the paper is withdrawn or desk rejected, I thought we were doing that already.

melisabok commented 11 months ago

Reopening this issue because the fix didn't work for the AC reviewing the reviewer's assignments.

One alternate solution is to load all the submissions: active, withdrawn and desk rejection so the counters match with the submission shown in the column, we could highlight the papers that are withdrawn and desk rejected. I think this is how TMLR works. What do you think? @xkopenreview