search

openrif / vivo-isf-ontology

The "VIVO-ISF Ontology" is an OWL2 representation of the VIVO-ISF Data Standard
16 stars 9 forks source link

Move c4o:BibliographicInformationSource to be subclass of vivo:Database, not http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ERO_0001716 #728

Open mconlon17 opened 6 years ago

mconlon17 commented 6 years ago

From Jon Corson-Rikert We need this class to be in a classgroup, and since it's heritage is from VIVO, I'd rather have it a subclass of vivo:Database rather than http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ERO_0001716, which is not in a classgroup and falls directly under Information Content Entity (http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/IAO_0000030)

https://jira.duraspace.org/browse/VIVO-642

mjaved495 commented 6 years ago

Question: Is BibliographicInformationSource always a Database ? If not, we cannot make this change. This change will have impact on the DATA.

mconlon17 commented 6 years ago

Some ontology changes will have impacts on existing triple stores. If the existence of the elements in existing triple stores is rare (1-5 sites, a few hundred instances) I have maked issues "medium". If significant training for many sites is needed to upgrade the triple store and rewrite queries, I have marked the issue "High". We can make any change. We should be very careful and conservative about making high impact changes.

I find no instances of BibliographicInformationSource in any of the data Dave Eichmann has collected from the VIVO sites.