search

openrif / vivo-isf-ontology

The "VIVO-ISF Ontology" is an OWL2 representation of the VIVO-ISF Data Standard
16 stars 9 forks source link

Move ERO_0000034 to application ontology and use only OBI_0000304? #730

Open mconlon17 opened 6 years ago

mconlon17 commented 6 years ago

From Jon Corson-Rikert:

In meeting with Brian, we first looked at the obi:Manufacturer – a defined class, and found we are missing the ManufacturerRole. obo:OBI_0000304 'manufactured by' (domain of Material Entity, range of Organization) is probably a shortcut to avoid having to create the Role and a Manufacturing Process when just trying to say who made the Entity. As to why two very similar properties, we'll have to check with Melissa.

What we have is more general than the Provenance ontology – the Provenance classes would be subclasses of ours - their idea of Attribution implies responsibility, while our generic Relationship is not so general. A manufacturer role may be accomplished by adding the Provenance classes and properties. Matt and Shahim looked at this at some level and the two core models can be aligned. This should be reviewed at the full VIVO-ISF level and then brought back.

https://jira.duraspace.org/browse/VIVO-1098

mjaved495 commented 6 years ago

It seems like a low impact change as we either create a new class or use an existing class where we do not need to change anything in the ontology.