search

openseg-group / OCNet.pytorch

Please choose the openseg.pytorch project for the updated code that achieve SOTA on 6 benchmarks!
MIT License
812 stars 128 forks source link

Issues about your paper writing. #33

Closed idealwei closed 5 years ago

idealwei commented 5 years ago

Hi, Its me again. I think you have submmited your paper already.

First of all, i want to say that i admire your work very much. But after reading your arXiv preprint version again, I found a serious problem that you haven't mentioned DANet or compare to it at all. DANet is accepted by ECCV2018 and i think both OCNet and DANet have very similar ideas and very close score on Cityscapes but with different interpretation. In my opinion, it's necessary to clarify the differece between them. However, you didn't for some reason. Can your try to explain ?

At last, hope your paper could be accepted.

PkuRainBow commented 5 years ago

Thanks for your kind remind.

.......DANet is after our work.... You could check the dates on the arxiv. I guess maybe DANet should mention our work in their paper.

We have released the paper about 2 weeks earlier than the DANet. OCNet is released on the arXiv on Sep/4 while DANet is Sep/16.

There also exist a related work PSANet accepted by the ECCV2018.

Besides, DANet is submitted to the AAAI-2019.

Anyway, we have added the citation of DANet in our newest version.