Closed romen closed 2 years ago
-0 from @mspncp ?
-0 from @mspncp ?
Yes, it is possible to vote -0 0 or +0. This is abstention with inclination against or for vote.
-0 from @mspncp ?
@tmshort please also note that I like your proposed change and consider it an improvement. I'm just inclined against backporting it because I think we should not lightheartedly undermine our own stable-release-updates policy, which we published only recently:
But you are right, -0 was an indecisive vote. So instead of leaving the decision up to Kurt who hasn't voted yet, I changed my mind and vote explicitly against it:
Vote: [-1] (corrected)
...instead of leaving the decision up to Kurt who hasn't voted yet...
Well, the vote still depends on @kroeckx's outstanding vote. Which proves that the ability to count properly is not a strict requirement for becoming a mathematician ;-)
Voting -1
-0 from @mspncp ?
@tmshort please also note that I like your proposed change and consider it an improvement. I'm just inclined against backporting it because I think we should not lightheartedly undermine our own stable-release-updates policy, which we published only recently:
But you are right, -0 was an indecisive vote. So instead of leaving the decision up to Kurt who hasn't voted yet, I changed my mind and vote explicitly against it:
Although openssl/openssl#18407 adds exactly 0 new tests or test cases, so we are not really voting an exception for that part of the policy, rather because we are considering this a new feature (not in the library or binaries, but in the test suite).
I plan to close the vote tomorrow (unless someone else does it sooner) in case there are changes of opinions.
Kurt voted -1; the sum() is -1, so the vote does not pass. I will close #18407 since it has already been merged to master.
I forgot to record this vote as closed, fixing it now:
Topic: Accept PR#18407 for backfit to 3.0 as a policy exception.
Proposed by: Nicola
Issue link: https://github.com/openssl/technical-policies/issues/52
Public: yes
Opened: 2022-05-31
Closed: 2022-06-07
Accepted: no (for: 3, against: 4, abstained: 3, not voted: 0)
Dmitry [+1]
Matt [-1]
Pauli [+1]
Tim [ 0]
Richard [ 0]
Shane [-1]
Tomas [ 0]
Kurt [-1]
Matthias [-1]
Nicola [+1]
The topic of this vote is: Accept PR#18407 for backfit to 3.0 as a policy exception.
The snippet below records the current votes as cast during the weekly OTC meeting (2022-05-31) during which the vote was called. The vote is still open.