Vineyards & Wineries

[SK53]

Currently iD expects to set both craft=winery with landuse=vineyard. I don't think this is appropriate, at least in Europe, for a range of reasons:

• many vineyards are not associated with wineries (particularly small scale vineyards in Europe which may sell their grapes to a co-operative winery. Furthermore the actual production of wine often occurs away from the vineyards. For instance the village of Kolimbari on Crete has a communal winery and each farmer brings their crop, usually heaped high on a trailer behind a tractor - large queues form.
• in some areas (notably Bourgogne) each individual vineyard (which may be impossible to discern as distinct from aerial imagery) has a distinct name (see Climats de Bourgogne), and many vineyards will be associated with the producer.
• larger wineries often represent tourism destinations in their own right with associated infrastructure of car parks, warehousing & logistics.
• vineyards associated with a winery may be highly dispersed, or inter-digitated amongst vineyards of other producers.
• vineyards are easy to locate on aerial imagery, the production facilities less so.

I would therefore suggest that the validation rules calling landuse=vineyard without craft=winery as "incomplete tagging" be dropped.

[quincylvania]

@SK53 Where are you seeing this? iD should only recommend crop=grape on landuse=vineyard. Wineries are separate.

[quincylvania]

Lacking further info, I'm closing this as unreproducible.