Closed ferdi2005 closed 3 years ago
Which behavior would you expect instead?
@sun-geo I’d expect to see it as an area, greyed out or with some indication of disused. I’d certainly not expect to see it as a line.
Hi and welcome, @ferdi2005. This happens because OSM doesn't have a separate area
geometry type, so iD guesses what's an area based on the tags. Since iD didn't know whether disused:amenity
should be an area, it falls back to line. You can add area=yes
to anything like this to make it an area.
I added an unsearchable Disused Amenity preset to fix this.
@quincylvania and can’t you add that iD recognizes disused:amenity as an area tag like amenity?
can’t you add that iD recognizes disused:amenity as an area tag like amenity?
Yes, this is what I did here:
I added an unsearchable Disused Amenity preset to fix this.
@quincylvania Thanks!
I added an unsearchable Disused Amenity preset to fix this.
The issue also applies to buildings, both disused: and abandoned: . In addition, these buildings no longer appear on the OSM map. I'm tempted to use building=house & disused=yes instead of disused:house=yes even though this is discouraged, because the issue doesn't occur here. I think disused:house=yes should be displayed the same as building=house & disused=yes (brick red area with dotted perimeter).
@rhhsm Yes, there are many combinations of status:key
that people use in OpenStreetMap, but I think it'd be over-the-top to try and support all of them as presets. I'd discourage using the disused:building
tag specifically, since a building is still a building even when no one is using it.
Consensus on the OSM wiki is that the simple tag is discouraged in favour of the prefix for reasons given here for instance https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:abandoned: I think the software should be adapted to the consensus, not the other way around. Probably to create presets for all cases is not the most elegant solution (but I'm not a coder).
1) https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:abandoned is for abandoned, not disused
2) https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:abandoned specifically indicates that building=*
+ abandoned=yes
is superior to abandoned:building
3) I just edited https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:disused: to indicate that disused:building
is a bad idea (feel free to discuss it on wiki/tagging mailing list/OSM Telegram/US Slack/...)
Your link lost the :
. Right is: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:disused:
Your link lost the :
Thanks, fixed. Github tried to be helpful and delinked trailing :
If I use disused:amenity as tag and theatre as value, the areas becomes a line.