search

openstreetmap / id-tagging-schema

🆔🏷 The presets and other tagging data used by the iD editor
ISC License
160 stars 164 forks source link

amenity=charging_station -> Which vehicles can be charged here? #1085

Open qugebert opened 9 months ago

qugebert commented 9 months ago

OSM Tag(s)

amenity=charging_station

How would you like this tag to see supported?

As a Field

Label

Supported vehicles

Aliases

No response

Terms

No response

Link to OSM Wiki page

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Dcharging_station

Status of the Tag

Approved

Usage of the tag

combinations from https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/amenity=charging_station#combinations bicycle= 12 283 motorcar= 36 026 motorcycle= 2 035 hgv https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/hgv= 1 041 bus - not found as combination on taginfo moped- not found as combination on taginfo

Replaces other Tag?

No response

Regional Tag?

global

Further Information

So the problem ist, that amenity=charging_station is used for charging stations for all vehicles. But normally, charging stations for pedelecs cannot used for charging cars and vice versa.

In some touristic regions these e-bike/pedelec charging stations are currently upcoming, and to avoid misunderstandings it would be nice to explicitely ask users that add charging stations for what vehicle they are intended.

Sommething like the activity-field for guidepost.

tyrasd commented 9 months ago

maybe it's also worth to additionally create new vehicle dependent presets (e.g. bike charging station, car charging station), for better discoverability while searching and also to allow for vehicle dependent fields (e.g. different charging ports on cars vs. bikes).

qugebert commented 9 months ago

maybe it's also worth to additionally create new vehicle dependent presets (e.g. bike charging station, car charging station), for better discoverability while searching and also to allow for vehicle dependent fields (e.g. different charging ports on cars vs. bikes).

sounds good. Maybe i will try this on my own the next days. Is it neccesary to find new icons or can both of these presets have the same/existing icon?

tyrasd commented 8 months ago

Is it neccesary to find new icons or can both of these presets have the same/existing icon?

Ideally yes, but I would say don't worry too much about it: if you cannot find one, it is still fine to reuse the icon from the generic preset.

FYI: I've just created https://github.com/ideditor/schema-builder/issues/135 for a possible enhancement to the preset schema to make the icon-ification of such presets potentially much easier.