Open Dimitar5555 opened 1 month ago
Features tagged with railway=ventilation_shaft and without other "area" tags are rendered as rails.
I am pretty sure this is something for the iD Repo. @tyrasd can move the issue if that is true.
Expected behavior Render them as areas?
That sounds like the right thing to do IMO. That is, if we want to create a special rule for a usage of just 1.6k.
It would be nice to have a preset but there is also the competing tag man_made=ventilation_shaft...
Given just 1.6k usage https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=railway%3Dventilation_shaft#tags I don't think this tag is used enough to get it's own preset ATM. We would
https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=man_made=ventilation_shaft#tags has 2.2 k usage. Also not a lot and not a big difference. Do we have documentation on which is to be considered preferred? We could create an unsearchable preset for "the other".
Of course we don't have documentation and we don't know which one is preferred...
This is solvable without creating a preset, the tag just needs to be added here:
Linear features require a slightly different approach, see https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/pull/9142 which fixed the issue for railway=platform_edge
Describe the bug Features tagged with
railway=ventilation_shaft
and without other "area" tags are rendered as rails.To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:
Expected behavior Render them as areas?
Screenshots![image](https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/assets/19364673/92bc6be2-3f78-4199-b97e-b8e4362df835)
Additional context It would be nice to have a preset but there is also the competing tag
man_made=venttilation_shaft
...