openstreetmap / id-tagging-schema

🆔🏷 The presets and other tagging data used by the iD editor
ISC License
160 stars 163 forks source link

Add fields compressed_air; toilets; internet_access; internet_access:fee and fast_food to amenity=fuel #1268

Open Oivo35 opened 5 months ago

Oivo35 commented 5 months ago

OSM Tag(s)

compressed_air=; toilets=; internet_access=; internet_access:fee=; fast_food=*

How would you like this tag to see supported?

As an Option of a Field

Label

fuel;compressed_air;internet_access;toilets;fast_food

Aliases

No response

Terms

No response

Link to OSM Wiki page

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity=fuel

Status of the Tag

Approved

Usage of the tag

49 600

Replaces other Tag?

No response

Regional Tag?

global

Further Information

amenity=fuel

matkoniecz commented 1 month ago

internet_access ? Is it really common for fuel stations to offer wifi? With just 4k tagged worldwide promoting this tagging seems dubious

the same for barely used fast_food

Oivo35 commented 1 month ago

Today's gas stations usually offer some kind of fast food and are often equipped with an internet connection for customers to pay via apps or to access to loyalty program. For example, most gas station chains in Europe are equipped in this way.

matkoniecz commented 1 month ago

are often equipped with an internet connection for customers to pay via apps or to access to loyalty program. For example, most gas station chains in Europe are equipped in this way.

this seems really dubious for me, as across Europe availability of mobile data is more and more standard

Today's gas stations usually offer some kind of fast food

pushing tagging it in this way via default editor, while this tagging nearly does not exist in practice seems dubious at best

Oivo35 commented 1 month ago

this seems really dubious for me, as across Europe availability of mobile data is more and more standard

amenity=fuel + internet_access - 4376 uses, amenity=fuel + fax - 1259 uses and this tag has its own field. amenity=fuel + level - 1088 and has own field, amenity=social_facility + internet_access - 325 uses and has own field.

pushing tagging it in this way via default editor, while this tagging nearly does not exist in practice seems dubious at best

Another example: amenity=cinema + min_age= - 77 uses and has its own field This combination is documented on wiki as well as the combination of amenity=fuel + fast_food=.