Enhance camp_site and caravan_site preset fields

[hiddewie]

I would like to request a number of fields to be added to the tourism camp_site and caravan_site presets:

• tents (yes/no)
• caravans (yes/no)
• static_caravans (yes/no)
• backcountry (yes/no)
• group_only (yes/no)
• nudism

The reason that these fields are important, is for finding a camp site with a certain vehicle or with a tent. Without these properties, camp sites may not allow access for camping with the vehicle/tent at hand. Situations like this occur when:

• A camp site is visited where nudism is the norm, but the visitors would rather not camp in a nude manner
• A camp site is paved with asphalt and cannot facilitate pitching tents
• A caravan site only allows static caravans, and no overnight camping with any vehicle/tent
• A camp site only allows tents and does not allow caravans or other large vehicles.
• A camp site only allows groups
• A camp site only allows private / members only access

Editors like iD and JOSM are the first point to improve the tagging experience for mappers. JOSM has a good preset, but the iD preset is lacking the required fields.

The open camping map visualizes this well.

Also see this tagging mailing list conversation about differentiating caravan_site and camp_site.

---

If I can make the time I will also try a pull request for this enhancement.

---

iD screenshot of camp_site preset:

JOSM screenshot of camp_site preset:

//edit @tyrasd

checklist for proposed fields:

• [x] tents #749
• [x] caravans #750
• [x] static_caravans #751
• [x] picnic_table #745
• [ ] backcountry
• [ ] group_only
• [x] nudism #752

[dustinblainemyers]

I added this under "fields" instead of "moreFields" since I saw you use the words "required" and "important" in your request. Let me know if this was the incorrect interpretation and I can fix it. I believe I followed the correct procedures according to the contributing guidelines but this is my first time contributing. Let me know if I can improve on anything.

Example of Change Under "Backcountry Camping Area " feature:

Link to pull request:

https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/pull/7955/commits

[hiddewie]

@dustinblainemyers Thanks for implementing this request! It looks really good, and will hopefully improve the tagging of campings and caravan sites!

[dustinblainemyers]

Awesome! Glad I could help.

[TheAdventurer64]

Shouldn't this be closed by now?

[hiddewie]

The pull request that implements this feature is still open, and once it is merged this issue can be closed (automatically?).

[osmuser63783]

I think this issue can be closed, as the fields requested are all part of the preset? Plus separate presets for backcountry and group-only campsites.

[tordans]

All right. I did not check it in detail but I see a few linked PRs. Please create a new issue if something is missing.

[hiddewie]

Thanks everybody involved for the work improving this preset!