search

openstreetmap / operations

OSMF Operations Working Group issue tracking
https://operations.osmfoundation.org/
99 stars 12 forks source link

Block *.yandex.net imagery #1033

Closed deevroman closed 9 months ago

deevroman commented 9 months ago

Problem

Yandex Maps satellite images are not allowed to be used in OSM

Description

Example of use:

https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/147580817

The domain on which they are located is: https://core-sat.maps.yandex.net/tiles?.....

In addition, Yandex has the Tiles API, which should also be blocked:

https://yandex.ru/dev/tiles/doc/ru/quickstart

https://tiles.api-maps.yandex.ru/....

Screenshots

No response

tomhughes commented 9 months ago

This is an operational issue, not a web site issue.

tomhughes commented 9 months ago

Requests to change the imagery blacklist need to come from DWG as described in https://github.com/openstreetmap/chef/pull/623.

grischard commented 9 months ago

In the DWG chat, one comment was that if there's a block, it should be on *.maps.yandex.net because they have file hosting, image hosting etc. on that domain that has nothing to do with their maps.

AntonKhorev commented 9 months ago

When using yandex.ru/maps/

https://core-sat.maps.yandex.net/ = aerial imagery https://core-renderer-tiles.maps.yandex.net/ = map tiles other kind of tiles are also under maps.yandex.net

talllguy commented 9 months ago

It does not appear that yandex is in the imagery index, though it was proposed once here.

pnorman commented 9 months ago

In the DWG chat, one comment was that if there's a block, it should be on *.maps.yandex.net because they have file hosting, image hosting etc. on that domain that has nothing to do with their maps.

Has the DWG decided to request a change to the blacklist?

grischard commented 9 months ago

Green light from dwg for blocklisting:

.api-maps.yandex.ru .maps.yandex.net

tomhughes commented 9 months ago

I thought @AntonKhorev said all the actual map tiles were under the maps.yandex.net domain?

tomhughes commented 9 months ago

Actually maybe I misunderstood what he was saying... Blocked both in https://github.com/openstreetmap/chef/commit/92d4fd1e5f12a09f6937872834cc048b91e3e7fc.

AntonKhorev commented 9 months ago

maps.yandex.net has all tiles as used by the official yandex map app

api-maps.yandex.ru has tiles that anyone with an api key can use