OTP bug plan request on route calculation by bus

fanycolle commented 4 years ago

Hello, I have a problem with your library . When a choose BUS-WALK by clicking on the map, in some solutions proposed by the opendata, I see a strange intermediate step (please see the picture attached) in somewhere in Africa. I'm sure about the effectiveness by the opendata. It seems a bug in your software. Could you please verify? Thank you in advance!

Francesca

otpresult

abyrd commented 4 years ago

Hello, as stated in the issue template, we would need specific information to allow your problem to be investigated, including the input data files. Of course a bug is possible, but it seems likely to me that this is due to incorrect input data.

fanycolle commented 4 years ago

Hello, as stated in the issue template, we would need specific information to allow your problem to be investigated, including the input data files. Of course a bug is possible, but it seems likely to me that this is due to incorrect input data.

Hello, as stated in the issue template, we would need specific information to allow your problem to be investigated, including the input data files. Of course a bug is possible, but it seems likely to me that this is due to incorrect input data.

Hi,

I took the file otp-1.4.0.jar from here: https://repo1.maven.org/maven2/org/opentripplanner/otp/1.4.0/ this jar:

and execute it with command: java -Xmx4G -jar otp-1.4.0-shaded.jar --build D:\utils\tmp\graphs\current --inMemory

in my folder D:\utils\tmp\graphs\current I have: google_transit.zip from http://dati.comune.lecce.it/trasporti/gtfs/google_transit.zip but resource now it's not available. You can find old open data here: https://transit.land/feed-registry/operators/o-srhv-sgmspa

This is my router-config.json:

{ "timeouts": [20, 20, 20], "routingDefaults": { "walkSpeed": 1.3, "transferSlack": 120, "maxTransfers": 4, "waitReluctance": 0.99, "waitAtBeginningFactor": 0.4, "walkReluctance": 1.75, "stairsReluctance": 1.65, "walkBoardCost": 540, "compactLegsByReversedSearch": false, "walkOnStreetReluctance": 1.5, "carParkCarLegWeight": 2, "itineraryFiltering": 2.0 },

"updaters": [ ], "boardTimes": { "AIRPLANE": 2700 }, "alightTimes": { "AIRPLANE": 1200 } }

This is my build-config.json:

{ "areaVisibility": true, "staticParkAndRide": true, "parentStopLinking": true, "subwayAccessTime": 0, "elevationUnitMultiplier": 0.1, "vertexConnector": "HSL" }

Result of otp is this: `{

"debugOutput": { "pathCalculationTime": 8, "timedOut": false, "precalculationTime": 23, "totalTime": 32, "renderingTime": 1, "pathTimes": [ 5, 2, 1 ] }, "requestParameters": { "date": "11/07/2019", "wheelchair": "false", "fromPlace": "40.3387688,18.1254198", "fuel": "default", "weight": "default", "maxWalkDistance": "2000", "locale": "it", "numItineraries": "3", "mode": "BUS,WALK", "arriveBy": "false", "carType": "default", "sexPerson": "default", "optimize": "QUICK", "showIntermediateStops": "true", "toPlace": "40.3557389,18.193174", "time": "4:00 PM" }, "plan": { "date": 1573138800000, "itineraries": [ { "walkDistance": 1449.9763846212672, "transitTime": 1920, "walkTime": 1155, "waitingTime": 182, "walkLimitExceeded": false, "elevationGained": 0, "tooSloped": false, "duration": 3257, "transfers": 1, "legs": [ { "legGeometry": { "length": 18, "points": "gteuFybsmB??Y}EW}D_AiOKwAW}DIsAK}AAIk@cJa@mGDSHINEPFfA~BHN" }, "transitLeg": false, "distance": 980.9970000000001, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "departureDelay": 0, "steps": [ { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Arnesano", "distance": 869.254, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.12541976608542, "absoluteDirection": "EAST", "relativeDirection": "DEPART", "lat": 40.33876897342273 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Monteroni", "distance": 111.74300000000001, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.1355431, "absoluteDirection": "SOUTHEAST", "relativeDirection": "RIGHT", "lat": 40.3400219 } ], "realTime": false, "mode": "WALK", "duration": 771, "route": "", "pathway": false, "startTime": 1573139048000, "from": { "vertexType": "NORMAL", "orig": "", "name": "Origin", "lon": 18.1254198, "departure": 1573139048000, "lat": 40.3387688 }, "endTime": 1573139819000, "to": { "stopIndex": 19, "stopCode": "387", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 20, "arrival": 1573139819000, "name": "Monteroni - Prima Incrocio Via", "stopId": "1:287", "lon": 18.135003, "departure": 1573139820000, "lat": 40.339325 }, "rentedBike": false, "intermediateStops": [], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 8, "points": "wweuFw~tmBuSkd@uNsj@gDuNmDyNwGoYvAgNcEmP" }, "transitLeg": true, "distance": 2613.0216834758016, "serviceDate": "20191107", "agencyId": "104", "tripId": "1:0000165692019091620200613", "departureDelay": 0, "routeLongName": "Porta Napoli - Ecotekne", "mode": "BUS", "duration": 480, "routeId": "1:20", "agencyUrl": "http://www.sgmlecce.it", "startTime": 1573139820000, "from": { "stopIndex": 19, "stopCode": "387", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 20, "arrival": 1573139819000, "name": "Monteroni - Prima Incrocio Via", "stopId": "1:287", "lon": 18.135003, "departure": 1573139820000, "lat": 40.339325 }, "rentedBike": false, "routeType": 3, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "steps": [], "agencyName": "S.G.M. S.p.A.", "realTime": false, "routeShortName": "27EXP", "route": "27EXP", "pathway": false, "endTime": 1573140300000, "to": { "stopIndex": 26, "stopCode": "371", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 27, "arrival": 1573140300000, "name": "Diaz, 38", "stopId": "1:271", "lon": 18.162479, "departure": 1573140480000, "lat": 40.348799 }, "intermediateStops": [ { "stopIndex": 20, "stopCode": "382", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 21, "arrival": 1573139880000, "name": "Monteroni - Villa Verde (382)", "stopId": "1:282", "lon": 18.140983, "departure": 1573139880000, "lat": 40.342636 }, { "stopIndex": 21, "stopCode": "380", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 22, "arrival": 1573139940000, "name": "Monteroni - Caserma Nacci", "stopId": "1:280", "lon": 18.147967, "departure": 1573139940000, "lat": 40.345145 }, { "stopIndex": 22, "stopCode": "378", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 23, "arrival": 1573140000000, "name": "Monteroni - Fronte Fermata 377", "stopId": "1:278", "lon": 18.150471, "departure": 1573140000000, "lat": 40.345987 }, { "stopIndex": 23, "stopCode": "376", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 24, "arrival": 1573140060000, "name": "Monteroni - Acquedotto", "stopId": "1:276", "lon": 18.153004, "departure": 1573140060000, "lat": 40.346851 }, { "stopIndex": 24, "stopCode": "374", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 25, "arrival": 1573140180000, "name": "Massaglia, 56", "stopId": "1:274", "lon": 18.157247, "departure": 1573140180000, "lat": 40.348251 }, { "stopIndex": 25, "stopCode": "342", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 26, "arrival": 1573140240000, "name": "Rudiae - Prima Sottopasso Vers", "stopId": "1:242", "lon": 18.159688, "departure": 1573140240000, "lat": 40.347812 } ], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 14, "points": "}rguFmjzmBsIaFxIyPxNP{EoNv@iPgGaJnEj[tfifCeclfC_yjfCx_jfCqEgYaCqOiBuIaDiR" }, "transitLeg": true, "distance": 6508880.14231047, "serviceDate": "20191107", "agencyId": "104", "tripId": "1:0000163252019091620200613", "departureDelay": 0, "routeLongName": "167B - Centro - Ospedale", "mode": "BUS", "duration": 1440, "routeId": "1:4", "agencyUrl": "http://www.sgmlecce.it", "startTime": 1573140480000, "from": { "stopIndex": 6, "stopCode": "371", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 7, "arrival": 1573140300000, "name": "Diaz, 38", "stopId": "1:271", "lon": 18.162479, "departure": 1573140480000, "lat": 40.348799 }, "rentedBike": false, "routeType": 3, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "steps": [], "agencyName": "S.G.M. S.p.A.", "realTime": false, "routeShortName": "24", "route": "24", "pathway": false, "endTime": 1573141920000, "to": { "stopIndex": 19, "stopCode": "175", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 20, "arrival": 1573141920000, "name": "Della Liberta' - Super Mac", "stopId": "1:142", "lon": 18.191275, "departure": 1573141921000, "lat": 40.358422 }, "intermediateStops": [ { "stopIndex": 7, "stopCode": "177", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 8, "arrival": 1573140600000, "name": "Gallipoli - Bar Rosso E Nero", "stopId": "1:92", "lon": 18.163604, "departure": 1573140600000, "lat": 40.350496 }, { "stopIndex": 8, "stopCode": "179", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 9, "arrival": 1573140720000, "name": "Gallipoli - Case Incis, 9", "stopId": "1:94", "lon": 18.166452, "departure": 1573140720000, "lat": 40.348764 }, { "stopIndex": 9, "stopCode": "137", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 10, "arrival": 1573140900000, "name": "Quarta O. - Stazione", "stopId": "1:54", "lon": 18.166369, "departure": 1573140900000, "lat": 40.346233 }, { "stopIndex": 10, "stopCode": "138", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 11, "arrival": 1573141020000, "name": "Gallipoli - Intendenza Di Fin", "stopId": "1:55", "lon": 18.168849, "departure": 1573141020000, "lat": 40.347338 }, { "stopIndex": 11, "stopCode": "109", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 12, "arrival": 1573141140000, "name": "Otranto - Bar Otranto, 11", "stopId": "1:31", "lon": 18.171617, "departure": 1573141140000, "lat": 40.347058 }, { "stopIndex": 12, "stopCode": "110", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 13, "arrival": 1573141260000, "name": "Otranto - Piazza Italia", "stopId": "1:32", "lon": 18.173386, "departure": 1573141260000, "lat": 40.348378 }, { "stopIndex": 13, "stopCode": "115", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 14, "arrival": 1573141380000, "name": "Gallipoli - Intendenza Di Fin", "stopId": "1:10", "lon": 18.168849, "departure": 1573141380000, "lat": 40.347338 }, { "stopIndex": 14, "stopCode": "102", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 15, "arrival": 1573141440000, "name": "Cavallotti, 21", "stopId": "1:11", "lon": 40.354472, "departure": 1573141440000, "lat": 18.176506 }, { "stopIndex": 15, "stopCode": "166", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 16, "arrival": 1573141560000, "name": "Imperatore Adriano - Chiesa D", "stopId": "1:41", "lon": 18.179628, "departure": 1573141560000, "lat": 40.355387 }, { "stopIndex": 16, "stopCode": "168", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 17, "arrival": 1573141650000, "name": "Del Mare - Edicola, 18", "stopId": "1:43", "lon": 18.183825, "departure": 1573141650000, "lat": 40.356435 }, { "stopIndex": 17, "stopCode": "237", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 18, "arrival": 1573141740000, "name": "Della Liberta' , 77", "stopId": "1:137", "lon": 18.186478, "departure": 1573141740000, "lat": 40.357085 }, { "stopIndex": 18, "stopCode": "239", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 19, "arrival": 1573141830000, "name": "Della Liberta' - Vicino Tabac", "stopId": "1:139", "lon": 18.188185, "departure": 1573141830000, "lat": 40.357611 } ], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 19, "points": "ioiuFi~_nBDVH^dBs@TIvBKhBKA?^Et@MN?LGDCBU@sAAG?IG_BEeB" }, "transitLeg": false, "distance": 468.81899999999996, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "departureDelay": 0, "steps": [ { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "service road", "distance": 25.542, "bogusName": true, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.19125726443742, "absoluteDirection": "WEST", "relativeDirection": "DEPART", "lat": 40.358457133140206 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Sant'Elia", "distance": 73.557, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.1909752, "absoluteDirection": "SOUTH", "relativeDirection": "LEFT", "lat": 40.3583761 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Pitagora", "distance": 228.966, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.191284200000002, "absoluteDirection": "SOUTH", "relativeDirection": "CONTINUE", "lat": 40.3577579 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "exit": "1", "streetName": "Via Pitagora", "distance": 3.76, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.1915407, "absoluteDirection": "SOUTHEAST", "relativeDirection": "CIRCLE_CLOCKWISE", "lat": 40.3557128 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Viale Aldo Moro", "distance": 136.994, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.191565, "absoluteDirection": "EAST", "relativeDirection": "LEFT", "lat": 40.3556845 } ], "realTime": false, "mode": "WALK", "duration": 384, "route": "", "pathway": false, "startTime": 1573141921000, "from": { "stopIndex": 19, "stopCode": "175", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 20, "arrival": 1573141920000, "name": "Della Liberta' - Super Mac", "stopId": "1:142", "lon": 18.191275, "departure": 1573141921000, "lat": 40.358422 }, "endTime": 1573142305000, "to": { "vertexType": "NORMAL", "arrival": 1573142305000, "orig": "", "name": "Destination", "lon": 18.193174, "lat": 40.3557389 }, "rentedBike": false, "intermediateStops": [], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false } ], "elevationLost": 0, "startTime": 1573139048000, "endTime": 1573142305000 }, { "walkDistance": 1738.0823077032128, "transitTime": 1620, "walkTime": 1411, "waitingTime": 297, "walkLimitExceeded": false, "elevationGained": 0, "tooSloped": false, "duration": 3328, "transfers": 1, "legs": [ { "legGeometry": { "length": 18, "points": "gteuFybsmB??Y}EW}D_AiOKwAW}DIsAK}AAIk@cJa@mGDSHINEPFfA~BHN" }, "transitLeg": false, "distance": 980.9970000000001, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "departureDelay": 0, "steps": [ { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Arnesano", "distance": 869.254, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.12541976608542, "absoluteDirection": "EAST", "relativeDirection": "DEPART", "lat": 40.33876897342273 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Monteroni", "distance": 111.74300000000001, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.1355431, "absoluteDirection": "SOUTHEAST", "relativeDirection": "RIGHT", "lat": 40.3400219 } ], "realTime": false, "mode": "WALK", "duration": 771, "route": "", "pathway": false, "startTime": 1573139768000, "from": { "vertexType": "NORMAL", "orig": "", "name": "Origin", "lon": 18.1254198, "departure": 1573139768000, "lat": 40.3387688 }, "endTime": 1573140539000, "to": { "stopIndex": 19, "stopCode": "387", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 20, "arrival": 1573140539000, "name": "Monteroni - Prima Incrocio Via", "stopId": "1:287", "lon": 18.135003, "departure": 1573140540000, "lat": 40.339325 }, "rentedBike": false, "intermediateStops": [], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 9, "points": "wweuFw~tmBuSkd@uNsj@gDuNmDyNwGoYvAgNcEmPsIaF" }, "transitLeg": true, "distance": 2824.435537778197, "serviceDate": "20191107", "agencyId": "104", "tripId": "1:0000165492019091620200613", "departureDelay": 0, "routeLongName": "P. Napoli - Ekotecne - Centro", "mode": "BUS", "duration": 600, "routeId": "1:7", "agencyUrl": "http://www.sgmlecce.it", "startTime": 1573140540000, "from": { "stopIndex": 19, "stopCode": "387", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 20, "arrival": 1573140539000, "name": "Monteroni - Prima Incrocio Via", "stopId": "1:287", "lon": 18.135003, "departure": 1573140540000, "lat": 40.339325 }, "rentedBike": false, "routeType": 3, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "steps": [], "agencyName": "S.G.M. S.p.A.", "realTime": false, "routeShortName": "27", "route": "27", "pathway": false, "endTime": 1573141140000, "to": { "stopIndex": 27, "stopCode": "177", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 28, "arrival": 1573141140000, "name": "Gallipoli - Bar Rosso E Nero", "stopId": "1:92", "lon": 18.163604, "departure": 1573141140000, "lat": 40.350496 }, "intermediateStops": [ { "stopIndex": 20, "stopCode": "382", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 21, "arrival": 1573140600000, "name": "Monteroni - Villa Verde (382)", "stopId": "1:282", "lon": 18.140983, "departure": 1573140600000, "lat": 40.342636 }, { "stopIndex": 21, "stopCode": "380", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 22, "arrival": 1573140660000, "name": "Monteroni - Caserma Nacci", "stopId": "1:280", "lon": 18.147967, "departure": 1573140660000, "lat": 40.345145 }, { "stopIndex": 22, "stopCode": "378", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 23, "arrival": 1573140720000, "name": "Monteroni - Fronte Fermata 377", "stopId": "1:278", "lon": 18.150471, "departure": 1573140720000, "lat": 40.345987 }, { "stopIndex": 23, "stopCode": "376", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 24, "arrival": 1573140780000, "name": "Monteroni - Acquedotto", "stopId": "1:276", "lon": 18.153004, "departure": 1573140780000, "lat": 40.346851 }, { "stopIndex": 24, "stopCode": "374", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 25, "arrival": 1573140900000, "name": "Massaglia, 56", "stopId": "1:274", "lon": 18.157247, "departure": 1573140900000, "lat": 40.348251 }, { "stopIndex": 25, "stopCode": "342", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 26, "arrival": 1573140960000, "name": "Rudiae - Prima Sottopasso Vers", "stopId": "1:242", "lon": 18.159688, "departure": 1573140960000, "lat": 40.347812 }, { "stopIndex": 26, "stopCode": "371", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 27, "arrival": 1573141020000, "name": "Diaz, 38", "stopId": "1:271", "lon": 18.162479, "departure": 1573141020000, "lat": 40.348799 } ], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 3, "points": "{}guFyqzmBA@AB" }, "transitLeg": false, "distance": 3.105, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "departureDelay": 0, "steps": [ { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Gallipoli - Bar Rosso E Nero => Gallipoli - Fronte Bar Rosso E", "distance": 3.105, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.163604, "absoluteDirection": "NORTHWEST", "relativeDirection": "DEPART", "lat": 40.350496 } ], "realTime": false, "mode": "WALK", "duration": 5, "route": "", "pathway": false, "startTime": 1573141140000, "from": { "stopIndex": 27, "stopCode": "177", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 28, "arrival": 1573141140000, "name": "Gallipoli - Bar Rosso E Nero", "stopId": "1:92", "lon": 18.163604, "departure": 1573141140000, "lat": 40.350496 }, "endTime": 1573141145000, "to": { "stopIndex": 2, "stopCode": "178.", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 3, "arrival": 1573141145000, "name": "Gallipoli - Fronte Bar Rosso E", "stopId": "1:93", "lon": 18.163741, "departure": 1573141440000, "lat": 40.35065 }, "rentedBike": false, "intermediateStops": [], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 11, "points": "q~guFkrzmBoD{AeRyJcOiHoMcHaIkHyGeLz@iZIcVbPeOzRgJ" }, "transitLeg": true, "distance": 3033.663470522269, "serviceDate": "20191107", "agencyId": "104", "tripId": "1:0000164632019091620200613", "departureDelay": 0, "routeLongName": "Stazione FF.SS. - Porta Napoli - Viale Leopardi", "mode": "BUS", "duration": 1020, "routeId": "1:11", "agencyUrl": "http://www.sgmlecce.it", "startTime": 1573141440000, "from": { "stopIndex": 2, "stopCode": "178.", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 3, "arrival": 1573141145000, "name": "Gallipoli - Fronte Bar Rosso E", "stopId": "1:93", "lon": 18.163741, "departure": 1573141440000, "lat": 40.35065 }, "rentedBike": false, "routeType": 3, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "steps": [], "agencyName": "S.G.M. S.p.A.", "realTime": false, "routeShortName": "31", "route": "31", "pathway": false, "endTime": 1573142460000, "to": { "stopIndex": 12, "stopCode": "157", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 13, "arrival": 1573142460000, "name": "Japigia ,2D ( Vobis)", "stopId": "1:72", "lon": 18.185116, "departure": 1573142461000, "lat": 40.354694 }, "intermediateStops": [ { "stopIndex": 3, "stopCode": "175.", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 4, "arrival": 1573141500000, "name": "Dell'Universita' - Porta Rudi", "stopId": "1:90", "lon": 18.164205, "departure": 1573141500000, "lat": 40.351532 }, { "stopIndex": 4, "stopCode": "173", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 5, "arrival": 1573141620000, "name": "Dell'Universita' - Liceo Palm", "stopId": "1:88", "lon": 18.166093, "departure": 1573141620000, "lat": 40.354602 }, { "stopIndex": 5, "stopCode": "170", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 6, "arrival": 1573141710000, "name": "Parcheggio C.Pranzo", "stopId": "1:85", "lon": 18.167588, "departure": 1573141710000, "lat": 40.357181 }, { "stopIndex": 6, "stopCode": "168.", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 7, "arrival": 1573141770000, "name": "Calasso - Lato C. Pranzo", "stopId": "1:83", "lon": 18.169049, "departure": 1573141770000, "lat": 40.359501 }, { "stopIndex": 7, "stopCode": "167.", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 8, "arrival": 1573141860000, "name": "Foscolo - Lato Api, 2", "stopId": "1:82", "lon": 18.170543, "departure": 1573141860000, "lat": 40.361116 }, { "stopIndex": 8, "stopCode": "165", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 9, "arrival": 1573141920000, "name": "Foscolo - Fronte Chiesa", "stopId": "1:80", "lon": 18.172657, "departure": 1573141920000, "lat": 40.362528 }, { "stopIndex": 9, "stopCode": "162", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 10, "arrival": 1573141980000, "name": "Leopardi - Dopo Incrocio Via D", "stopId": "1:77", "lon": 18.177021, "departure": 1573141980000, "lat": 40.36223 }, { "stopIndex": 10, "stopCode": "160", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 11, "arrival": 1573142040000, "name": "Leopardi - Poco Prima Incroci", "stopId": "1:75", "lon": 18.180729, "departure": 1573142040000, "lat": 40.360611 }, { "stopIndex": 11, "stopCode": "159", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 12, "arrival": 1573142100000, "name": "Leopardi - Subito Dopo Rotator", "stopId": "1:74", "lon": 18.183315, "departure": 1573142400000, "lat": 40.357874 } ], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 47, "points": "ywhuF}w~mBA@o@VEBGWAKC?C??A?CK??GCcAEyAAOAOA[EoAMcECYCWAOYuCEY?UC[QgBAQW{CAQEc@Ba@D]@O?MAECM?KBKDIDCBU@sAAG?IG_BEeB" }, "transitLeg": false, "distance": 753.683, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "departureDelay": 0, "steps": [ { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Viale Japigia", "distance": 34.098, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.185111046145057, "absoluteDirection": "NORTH", "relativeDirection": "DEPART", "lat": 40.354692677115544 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "path", "distance": 29.276000000000003, "bogusName": true, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.184967, "absoluteDirection": "EAST", "relativeDirection": "RIGHT", "lat": 40.354979 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Benedetto Croce", "distance": 524.68, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.185172, "absoluteDirection": "EAST", "relativeDirection": "RIGHT", "lat": 40.3551246 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "exit": "3", "streetName": "Via Pitagora", "distance": 28.634999999999998, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.191275700000002, "absoluteDirection": "NORTHEAST", "relativeDirection": "CIRCLE_CLOCKWISE", "lat": 40.355732800000006 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Viale Aldo Moro", "distance": 136.994, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.191565, "absoluteDirection": "EAST", "relativeDirection": "LEFT", "lat": 40.3556845 } ], "realTime": false, "mode": "WALK", "duration": 635, "route": "", "pathway": false, "startTime": 1573142461000, "from": { "stopIndex": 12, "stopCode": "157", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 13, "arrival": 1573142460000, "name": "Japigia ,2D ( Vobis)", "stopId": "1:72", "lon": 18.185116, "departure": 1573142461000, "lat": 40.354694 }, "endTime": 1573143096000, "to": { "vertexType": "NORMAL", "arrival": 1573143096000, "orig": "", "name": "Destination", "lon": 18.193174, "lat": 40.3557389 }, "rentedBike": false, "intermediateStops": [], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false } ], "elevationLost": 0, "startTime": 1573139768000, "endTime": 1573143096000 }, { "walkDistance": 645.0793846183332, "transitTime": 2790, "walkTime": 520, "waitingTime": 122, "walkLimitExceeded": false, "elevationGained": 0, "tooSloped": false, "duration": 3432, "transfers": 1, "legs": [ { "legGeometry": { "length": 4, "points": "gteuFybsmB??Y}EW}D" }, "transitLeg": false, "distance": 176.18, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "departureDelay": 0, "steps": [ { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Arnesano", "distance": 176.18, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.12541976608542, "absoluteDirection": "EAST", "relativeDirection": "DEPART", "lat": 40.33876897342273 } ], "realTime": false, "mode": "WALK", "duration": 136, "route": "", "pathway": false, "startTime": 1573140973000, "from": { "vertexType": "NORMAL", "orig": "", "name": "Origin", "lon": 18.1254198, "departure": 1573140973000, "lat": 40.3387688 }, "endTime": 1573141109000, "to": { "stopIndex": 14, "stopCode": "384", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 15, "arrival": 1573141109000, "name": "Arnesano - Centro Tecnologico", "stopId": "1:284", "lon": 18.127449, "departure": 1573141110000, "lat": 40.339127 }, "rentedBike": false, "intermediateStops": [], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 19, "points": "oveuFoosmByA{]TkOlZjp@vEhKeHvnAhBoP}A{YoWaBuSkd@uNsj@gDuNmDyNwGoYvAgNcEmPsIaFxIyPxNP" }, "transitLeg": true, "distance": 8186.220648815445, "serviceDate": "20191107", "agencyId": "104", "tripId": "1:0000165272019091620200613", "departureDelay": 0, "routeLongName": "P. Napoli - Ekotecne - Centro", "mode": "BUS", "duration": 1770, "routeId": "1:7", "agencyUrl": "http://www.sgmlecce.it", "startTime": 1573141110000, "from": { "stopIndex": 14, "stopCode": "384", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 15, "arrival": 1573141109000, "name": "Arnesano - Centro Tecnologico", "stopId": "1:284", "lon": 18.127449, "departure": 1573141110000, "lat": 40.339127 }, "rentedBike": false, "routeType": 3, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "steps": [], "agencyName": "S.G.M. S.p.A.", "realTime": false, "routeShortName": "27", "route": "27", "pathway": false, "endTime": 1573142880000, "to": { "stopIndex": 32, "stopCode": "137", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 33, "arrival": 1573142880000, "name": "Quarta O. - Stazione", "stopId": "1:54", "lon": 18.166369, "departure": 1573143000000, "lat": 40.346233 }, "intermediateStops": [ { "stopIndex": 15, "stopCode": "385", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 16, "arrival": 1573141170000, "name": "Arnesano - Fronte Centro Villa", "stopId": "1:285", "lon": 18.13238, "departure": 1573141170000, "lat": 40.339575 }, { "stopIndex": 16, "stopCode": "386", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 17, "arrival": 1573141230000, "name": "Monteroni - Dopo Incrocio Via", "stopId": "1:286", "lon": 18.135005, "departure": 1573141230000, "lat": 40.339465 }, { "stopIndex": 17, "stopCode": "388", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 18, "arrival": 1573141290000, "name": "Monteroni - Carcere Minorile", "stopId": "1:288", "lon": 18.12711, "departure": 1573141290000, "lat": 40.335074 }, { "stopIndex": 18, "stopCode": "389", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 19, "arrival": 1573141350000, "name": "Monteroni - Fronte Istituto Su", "stopId": "1:289", "lon": 18.125134, "departure": 1573141350000, "lat": 40.333995 }, { "stopIndex": 19, "stopCode": "494", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 20, "arrival": 1573141530000, "name": "Ecotekne Fiorini", "stopId": "1:394", "lon": 18.112372, "departure": 1573141680000, "lat": 40.335469 }, { "stopIndex": 20, "stopCode": "496", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 21, "arrival": 1573141740000, "name": "Ecotekne Ingegneria", "stopId": "1:396", "lon": 18.115178, "departure": 1573141740000, "lat": 40.334938 }, { "stopIndex": 21, "stopCode": "495", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 22, "arrival": 1573141860000, "name": "Ecotekne Economia", "stopId": "1:395", "lon": 18.119475, "departure": 1573141860000, "lat": 40.335408 }, { "stopIndex": 22, "stopCode": "387", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 23, "arrival": 1573141980000, "name": "Monteroni - Prima Incrocio Via", "stopId": "1:287", "lon": 18.135003, "departure": 1573141980000, "lat": 40.339325 }, { "stopIndex": 23, "stopCode": "382", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 24, "arrival": 1573142040000, "name": "Monteroni - Villa Verde (382)", "stopId": "1:282", "lon": 18.140983, "departure": 1573142040000, "lat": 40.342636 }, { "stopIndex": 24, "stopCode": "380", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 25, "arrival": 1573142100000, "name": "Monteroni - Caserma Nacci", "stopId": "1:280", "lon": 18.147967, "departure": 1573142100000, "lat": 40.345145 }, { "stopIndex": 25, "stopCode": "378", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 26, "arrival": 1573142160000, "name": "Monteroni - Fronte Fermata 377", "stopId": "1:278", "lon": 18.150471, "departure": 1573142160000, "lat": 40.345987 }, { "stopIndex": 26, "stopCode": "376", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 27, "arrival": 1573142220000, "name": "Monteroni - Acquedotto", "stopId": "1:276", "lon": 18.153004, "departure": 1573142220000, "lat": 40.346851 }, { "stopIndex": 27, "stopCode": "374", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 28, "arrival": 1573142340000, "name": "Massaglia, 56", "stopId": "1:274", "lon": 18.157247, "departure": 1573142340000, "lat": 40.348251 }, { "stopIndex": 28, "stopCode": "342", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 29, "arrival": 1573142400000, "name": "Rudiae - Prima Sottopasso Vers", "stopId": "1:242", "lon": 18.159688, "departure": 1573142400000, "lat": 40.347812 }, { "stopIndex": 29, "stopCode": "371", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 30, "arrival": 1573142460000, "name": "Diaz, 38", "stopId": "1:271", "lon": 18.162479, "departure": 1573142460000, "lat": 40.348799 }, { "stopIndex": 30, "stopCode": "177", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 31, "arrival": 1573142580000, "name": "Gallipoli - Bar Rosso E Nero", "stopId": "1:92", "lon": 18.163604, "departure": 1573142580000, "lat": 40.350496 }, { "stopIndex": 31, "stopCode": "179", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 32, "arrival": 1573142700000, "name": "Gallipoli - Case Incis, 9", "stopId": "1:94", "lon": 18.166452, "departure": 1573142700000, "lat": 40.348764 } ], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 11, "points": "}bguFwb{mB{EoNv@iPgGaJnEj[tfifCeclfC_yjfCx_jfCqEgYaCqOiBuIaDiR" }, "transitLeg": true, "distance": 6508078.435166231, "serviceDate": "20191107", "agencyId": "104", "tripId": "1:0000163122019091620200613", "departureDelay": 0, "routeLongName": "167B - Centro - Ospedale", "mode": "BUS", "duration": 1020, "routeId": "1:4", "agencyUrl": "http://www.sgmlecce.it", "startTime": 1573143000000, "from": { "stopIndex": 45, "stopCode": "137", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 46, "arrival": 1573142880000, "name": "Quarta O. - Stazione", "stopId": "1:54", "lon": 18.166369, "departure": 1573143000000, "lat": 40.346233 }, "rentedBike": false, "routeType": 3, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "steps": [], "agencyName": "S.G.M. S.p.A.", "realTime": false, "routeShortName": "24", "route": "24", "pathway": false, "endTime": 1573144020000, "to": { "stopIndex": 55, "stopCode": "175", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 56, "arrival": 1573144020000, "name": "Della Liberta' - Super Mac", "stopId": "1:142", "lon": 18.191275, "departure": 1573144021000, "lat": 40.358422 }, "intermediateStops": [ { "stopIndex": 46, "stopCode": "138", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 47, "arrival": 1573143120000, "name": "Gallipoli - Intendenza Di Fin", "stopId": "1:55", "lon": 18.168849, "departure": 1573143120000, "lat": 40.347338 }, { "stopIndex": 47, "stopCode": "109", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 48, "arrival": 1573143240000, "name": "Otranto - Bar Otranto, 11", "stopId": "1:31", "lon": 18.171617, "departure": 1573143240000, "lat": 40.347058 }, { "stopIndex": 48, "stopCode": "110", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 49, "arrival": 1573143360000, "name": "Otranto - Piazza Italia", "stopId": "1:32", "lon": 18.173386, "departure": 1573143360000, "lat": 40.348378 }, { "stopIndex": 49, "stopCode": "115", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 50, "arrival": 1573143480000, "name": "Gallipoli - Intendenza Di Fin", "stopId": "1:10", "lon": 18.168849, "departure": 1573143480000, "lat": 40.347338 }, { "stopIndex": 50, "stopCode": "102", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 51, "arrival": 1573143540000, "name": "Cavallotti, 21", "stopId": "1:11", "lon": 40.354472, "departure": 1573143540000, "lat": 18.176506 }, { "stopIndex": 51, "stopCode": "166", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 52, "arrival": 1573143660000, "name": "Imperatore Adriano - Chiesa D", "stopId": "1:41", "lon": 18.179628, "departure": 1573143660000, "lat": 40.355387 }, { "stopIndex": 52, "stopCode": "168", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 53, "arrival": 1573143750000, "name": "Del Mare - Edicola, 18", "stopId": "1:43", "lon": 18.183825, "departure": 1573143750000, "lat": 40.356435 }, { "stopIndex": 53, "stopCode": "237", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 54, "arrival": 1573143840000, "name": "Della Liberta' , 77", "stopId": "1:137", "lon": 18.186478, "departure": 1573143840000, "lat": 40.357085 }, { "stopIndex": 54, "stopCode": "239", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 55, "arrival": 1573143930000, "name": "Della Liberta' - Vicino Tabac", "stopId": "1:139", "lon": 18.188185, "departure": 1573143930000, "lat": 40.357611 } ], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false }, { "legGeometry": { "length": 19, "points": "ioiuFi~_nBDVH^dBs@TIvBKhBKA?^Et@MN?LGDCBU@sAAG?IG_BEeB" }, "transitLeg": false, "distance": 468.81899999999996, "arrivalDelay": 0, "agencyTimeZoneOffset": 3600000, "departureDelay": 0, "steps": [ { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "service road", "distance": 25.542, "bogusName": true, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.19125726443742, "absoluteDirection": "WEST", "relativeDirection": "DEPART", "lat": 40.358457133140206 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Sant'Elia", "distance": 73.557, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.1909752, "absoluteDirection": "SOUTH", "relativeDirection": "LEFT", "lat": 40.3583761 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Via Pitagora", "distance": 228.966, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.191284200000002, "absoluteDirection": "SOUTH", "relativeDirection": "CONTINUE", "lat": 40.3577579 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "exit": "1", "streetName": "Via Pitagora", "distance": 3.76, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.1915407, "absoluteDirection": "SOUTHEAST", "relativeDirection": "CIRCLE_CLOCKWISE", "lat": 40.3557128 }, { "area": false, "elevation": [], "streetName": "Viale Aldo Moro", "distance": 136.994, "bogusName": false, "stayOn": false, "lon": 18.191565, "absoluteDirection": "EAST", "relativeDirection": "LEFT", "lat": 40.3556845 } ], "realTime": false, "mode": "WALK", "duration": 384, "route": "", "pathway": false, "startTime": 1573144021000, "from": { "stopIndex": 55, "stopCode": "175", "vertexType": "TRANSIT", "stopSequence": 56, "arrival": 1573144020000, "name": "Della Liberta' - Super Mac", "stopId": "1:142", "lon": 18.191275, "departure": 1573144021000, "lat": 40.358422 }, "endTime": 1573144405000, "to": { "vertexType": "NORMAL", "arrival": 1573144405000, "orig": "", "name": "Destination", "lon": 18.193174, "lat": 40.3557389 }, "rentedBike": false, "intermediateStops": [], "interlineWithPreviousLeg": false } ], "elevationLost": 0, "startTime": 1573140973000, "endTime": 1573144405000 } ], "from": { "vertexType": "NORMAL", "orig": "", "name": "Origin", "lon": 18.1254198, "lat": 40.3387688 }, "to": { "vertexType": "NORMAL", "orig": "", "name": "Destination", "lon": 18.193174, "lat": 40.3557389 } } }`

Thanks for response!!!

abyrd commented 4 years ago

Thanks for the information, especially links to the input data. That allows checking very quickly.

You can see on TransitLand (via the link you shared, and clicking Routes: View as an interactive map in Interline Mobility Explorer) that even outside OTP, other tools also show routes going into the Red Sea. Specifically it's route 16:

https://mobility-explorer.interline.io/#/routes?bbox=18.069292875536334%2C40.32317518779527%2C18.314160341862944%2C40.48210608485542&onestop_id=r-srhvt-16

If you look at the stops in Mobility Explorer, it seems there are no stops at that remote location. But if you click "Show stops served by route" when looking at route 16, it shows a stop "Cavallotti, 21" in the Red Sea.

Looking into the source data, in the stops table we have: 11,102,"Cavallotti, 21","Via Cesare Battisti, 4",18.176506,40.354472, Which appears to have the latitude and longitude fields reversed. This is a problem in the source data.

fanycolle commented 4 years ago

Yes, the problem was source data and latitude and longitude fields reverse on some stops! Thanks, I solved!

opentripplanner / OpenTripPlanner

OTP bug plan request on route calculation by bus #2873