Missing quays from Norway Netex data

[selaazdoudi]

Expected behavior

The graph build process should complete successfully without any errors.

Observed behavior

The graph build process fails with a NullPointerException related to the OrganisationsInFrame_RelStructure element in the Netex data. The specific error message is:

java.lang.NullPointerException: Cannot invoke "org.rutebanken.netex.model.OrganisationsInFrame_RelStructure.getOrganisation_()" because "elements" is null

Version of OTP used (exact commit hash or JAR name)

Version: 2.2.0 Commit hash: 0ccb4b4f33c0f21cb981b84b320d49923f26e437 Branch: temp-release

Data sets in use (links to GTFS and OSM PBF files)

Netex file: rb_norway-aggregated-netex-2 OSM PBF file: norway-latest.osm.pbf

Command line used to start OTP

I am starting OTP from R log1 <- otp_build_graph( otp = path_otp, # Path to otp-2.2.0-shaded.jar dir = file.path(path_data), # Full path to the norway folder memory = 10240, # Allocate 10GB of memory router = "norway" # Use the norway router )

Router config and graph build config JSON

{ "areaVisibility": true, "platformEntriesLinking": true, "islandWithoutStopsMaxSize": 5, "islandWithStopsMaxSize": 5, "dataImportReport": true, "netexDefaults": { "moduleFilePattern": "rb_norway-aggregated-netex-2", "sharedFilePattern": "_stops.xml", "sharedGroupFilePattern": "_(\\w{3})(_flexible)?_shared_data.xml", "groupFilePattern": "(\\w{3})_.*\\.xml", "feedId": "EN", "ferryIdsNotAllowedForBicycle": [ "NYC:Line:1", "NYC:Line:012fc5c4-131b-4dfc-8160-4e49136e531a", "NYC:Line:8bfef12a-ac98-4376-8a2a-eb5a336d107b" ] }, "osm": [ { "source": "norway-latest.osm.pbf", "osmTagMapping": "norway", "timeZone": "Europe/Oslo" } ] }

Steps to reproduce the problem

library(opentripplanner) library(sf) path_data <- "/Users/salma/otp" dir.create(path_data, showWarnings = FALSE) path_otp <- otp_dl_jar(version = "2.2.0") log1 <- otp_build_graph( otp = path_otp, # Path to otp-2.2.0-shaded.jar dir = file.path(path_data), # Full path to the norway folder memory = 10240, # Allocate 10GB of memory router = "norway" # Use the norway router )

[t2gran]

Can you try to download data from here to make sure you have the latest and correct data set: https://storage.googleapis.com/marduk-production/outbound/netex/rb_norway-aggregated-netex.zip

We do not support using OTP as a library, but so before we look futher into this problem you will have to recreate the problem running OTP with java. I hope this helps...

[leonardehrenfried]

Also, you want to use the latest version of OTP.

2.2.0 is over 2 years old.

[selaazdoudi]

Thank you both for your answers Which versions of Java (and the corresponding OTP version) can handle NeTEx data the best? I can only use up to Java 17.

[leonardehrenfried]

OTP is continuously improved so my recommendation is to use OTP 2.6.0 and Java 21.

You can check the changelog when we switched to Java 21.