search

opentx / opentx

OpenTX custom firmware for Transmitters
GNU General Public License v2.0
2.07k stars 804 forks source link

Para bluetooth trainer not working when X-Lite Pro is master #7649

Open lthole opened 4 years ago

lthole commented 4 years ago

Similar to X10S Express issue #7094.

If I set up my X-Lite Pro as BT master, and my X9D+2019 as slave, the stick values next to Cal on the Trainer screen do not move, i.e. the slave does not come through.

Test No 1:

In the X9D+ SE 2019, I have the following: a) Bog standard model, 4channels AETR. b) In Hardware, Bluetooth is set for Trainer. c) In Model Page, Bluetooth is set as Slave/Bluetooth.

In the X-Lite Pro, I have the following: a) Model is set up for Slow Stick, channel order AETR. b) In Hardware, Bluetooth is set for Trainer. b) In Model Page, Bluetooth is set as Master/BT, then hit discover, and select the BT code for the slave. 'Discover' changes to 'Clear'. c) In Hardware page: Local addr 806FB0FE82F8 Dist addr 806FB0963467 d) In Special Functions, switch SD down enables Trainer function in Sticks mode, SF box checked.

  1. Power up model on X-Lite Pro, check servos and ESC work.
  2. Switch SD down.
  3. Slave does not control model. Look in Trainer page, the stick values next to Cal on the Trainer screen do not move.
  4. Check that the both addresses still show in Hardware page.

Test No 2:

Swap all above steps between X-Lite Pro and X9D+ SE 2019. The Trainer works as expected.

lthole commented 4 years ago

Both radios are on OpenTX 2.3.7. Probably not relevant to this issue: X-Lite Pro: ISRM-PRO 1.1.0/2.1.0 FCC X9D+ SE 2019: ISRM 1.1.0/2.1.0 FCC

bsongis commented 4 years ago

Are you sure you have flashed to BT module on both radios to the latest version?

bsongis commented 4 years ago

I just checked here, it works perfectly

kilrah commented 4 years ago

I don't think FrSky have published any BT firmware update... I can reproduce here

lthole commented 4 years ago

Further information: With the X-Lite Pro as master, and X9D+ SE 2019 as slave: a) As expected, the X-Lite shows both BT codes in the Hardware page: Local addr 806FB0FE82F8 Dist addr 806FB0963467

However: b) The X9D only shows Local addr 806FB0963467 Dist addr --- When testing the other way around, the slave was also showing both BT codes.

c) When I enable the Trainer function with switch SD down, the X-Lite still controls the model. I was expecting '0' to be used as slave values since the link is not functioning.

b14ckyy commented 3 years ago

Hey guys. I have the exact same problem. 100% identical to what @lthole describes. In my case it is a X10S BT module installed in a Radiomaster TX16S. Para trainer works when the X-Lite Pro is master. If I swap over the settings to make TX16S master, the trainer switch on the TX16S is just ignored and the X-Lite Pro slave is not given control. BT connection is stable and both radios show the distance addresses correct.

Both Radios are on 2.3.11 btw.

stale[bot] commented 3 years ago

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

b14ckyy commented 3 years ago

Is there any news about this? Not tested again.

brainbubblersbest commented 3 years ago

No. But you can solder the Para bt to your TX16S instead of the old Horus BT.

stale[bot] commented 2 years ago

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.