Issue create_switch.xml

patricktomassone commented 9 years ago

I have an issue when try to create a new switch with the following command:

netconf> edit-config --config=create_switch.xml running

NETCONF error: operation-failed (application) - Datastore fails to validate (Extra element logical-switches in interleave ) NETCONF error: operation-failed (application) - Datastore fails to validate (Element capable-switch failed to validate content )

And server side, have the following error:

ofc-server[20580]: RelaxNG validation on subdatastore 846930887 ofc-server[20580]: subdatastore 846930887 fails to validate

rkrejci commented 9 years ago

What is the result of the following command (I expect you are using netopeer-cli): netconf> validate running

And what is the current content of the running datastore, i.e the result of this command: netconf> get-config running

patricktomassone commented 9 years ago

I run netconf> validete running and the rusult is: Result OK

while the result of netconf> get-config running is: result

rkrejci commented 9 years ago

hmm, that's strange. When I apply create_switch.xml from netconf-tests to the same content, I get valid content. Try to force edit-config without validation and then, please share the content of the datastore:

netconf> edit-config --test set --config=create_switch.xml running

netconf> get-config running

patricktomassone commented 9 years ago

With the command netconf> edit-config --test set --config=create_switch.xml running, I solve the problem. Thanks a lot

rkrejci commented 9 years ago

no, you did not :) It just skip validation - run validate command on running after this command, you should get the same error. What is the content of the datastore after the edit-config? With --test set we just will be able to see the data that do not validate and get know why.

patricktomassone commented 9 years ago

Yes but the switch is successfully created.

result1

rkrejci commented 9 years ago

That is strange, now when you run

netconf> validate running

the validation fails, right? Because I can validate the same content successfully. Can you share the first lines of the server verbose messages (until the "OF-CONFIG server successfully initialized" line):

# ofc-server -v 5 -f

And, please, share the program listings not as a picture but as a text, it is much more useful for me. You can also use markdown to keep formatting of the text.

patricktomassone commented 9 years ago

When i run: netconf> valide running the output server side is:

patricktomassone commented 9 years ago

While the output when i create a new switch with --test set is:

patricktomassone commented 9 years ago

I don't have errors and obtain the correct configuration.

rkrejci commented 9 years ago

I'm lost in this :( And you ignored my questions so I'm no closer to solve the problem (because you had a problem and maybe still have a problem despite you don't see it).

There are 2 scenarios starting at the same point (maybe after the server start): 1) you run

netconf > edit-config --config create_switch.xml running

and you get validation error, right?

2) you run

netconf > edit-config --test set --config create_switch.xml running
netconf > validate running

and you get ok result? This confuses me, the result should be again error, if scenario 1 fails.

@cejkato2 , do you think that this can be somehow connected with a timing issue when communicating with OVS via OpenFlow protocol?

vinayakpattar commented 5 years ago

Hi, I am running validate running-- which is giving me following error. NETCONF error: operation-failed (application) - Datastore fails to validate (Extra element logical-switches in interleave) NETCONF error: operation-failed (application) - Datastore fails to validate (Element capable-switch failed to validate content) I am starting ofc server as 'sudo ofc-server -v 3 -f'. It would be helpful if anyone can help me out here. Thanks a lot. Vinayak

openvswitch / of-config

Issue create_switch.xml #19