One or two overviews - Githubissues

openwallet-foundation / digital-wallet-and-agent-overviews-sig

The objective of this SIG is to develop and maintain the Digital Wallets and Agents Overview. The overview should provide transparency of the characteristics of wallets and agents in order to allow for an objective comparison and effective decision making on which wallet or agent is applicable for your use case.

https://openwallet-foundation.github.io/digital-wallet-and-agent-overviews-sig/

Apache License 2.0

13 stars 24 forks source link

One or two overviews #2

Closed samuelmr closed 8 months ago

samuelmr commented 12 months ago

This repo will build upon TNO's Wallet Overview which is scoped to include holder wallets and Findynet's fork which extends the scope to solutions that have issuer and verifier capabilities.

Question: should we maintain two (possibly overlapping) overviews or one, combined overview?

Input from SSI solution vendors is appreciated.

samuelmr commented 12 months ago

Pros for maintaining two overviews:

less clutter for users interested in just wallets (agents with holder capabilities)
less clutter for users interested in just holistic solutions (issuer/verifier "platforms")

Cons for maintaining two overviews:

SSI solution vendors need to submit information to two different json files
duplicate maintenance of the same or very similar functionality (code)
in some cases, users would need to look for both overviews to find a solution (?)

cre8 commented 12 months ago

I would suggest to merge them and the user can filter the rows he/she wants to see. He/she is interacting with a web application and not a static list.

We did this approach for the credential comparison group and went fine with it.

samuelmr commented 8 months ago

The SIG has decided to merge.

Closing issue.