openwallet-foundation / digital-wallet-and-agent-overviews-sig

The objective of this SIG is to develop and maintain the Digital Wallets and Agents Overview. The overview should provide transparency of the characteristics of wallets and agents in order to allow for an objective comparison and effective decision making on which wallet or agent is applicable for your use case.
https://openwallet-foundation.github.io/digital-wallet-and-agent-overviews-sig/
Apache License 2.0
13 stars 24 forks source link

Linking to the credential profile comparison group #6

Closed cre8 closed 5 months ago

cre8 commented 10 months ago

We should use the resources from the https://github.com/openwallet-foundation/credential-format-comparison-sig to point to the existing resources. This would also allow to link back from the comparison group to wallets/agents practically supporting the credential profile or a resource like a key management approach.

The wallet entries have to reference the resource like a did:web entry points to: https://github.com/openwallet-foundation/credential-format-comparison-sig/blob/main/data/Key-Management/did.web.json

There are two options to implement it:

the wallet entries include the link of an existing entry

pro: we make sure there is a link to point to, no guessing

contra: it's more complicated since you need to know that there is a resource in another project. Since the vendors submit their wallet via a PR it's not a custom form field where we can force them to choose one of the existing elements.

Link guessing

We try to fetch the resource from the github like "is https://github.com/openwallet-foundation/credential-format-comparison-sig/blob/main/data/Key-Management/did.web.json reachable". if so, we can print a hyperlink. If not we just print text.

contra: in case the user writes did:Web we will not be able to fetch the resource. someone has to double check for the format.

samuelmr commented 5 months ago

I think we can close this issue. @cre8 do you agree?

cre8 commented 5 months ago

yes