search

operator-framework / operator-controller

Apache License 2.0
28 stars 47 forks source link

[Bug] Reconciliation of cluster extension content not working on main branch #983

Open skattoju opened 5 days ago

skattoju commented 5 days ago

Since we setup watches for all objects installed by a cluster extension. It is expected that the controller will reconcile cluster extension content in case any of it is modified. However this does not work as expected.

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Switch to main branch
  2. make run
  3. Deploy sample catalog
  4. Deploy sample extension
  5. Delete deployment of extension controller

Expected Result: The controller should react and recreate the deployment

Actual Result: The controller does not react

bentito commented 5 days ago

Hi, thanks for the bug report. So to check things out, I immediately ran make test-e2e. All pass and we think they're fairly realistic end-to-end tests, so... Any chance you could reframe this bug report more along the lines of these tests (or at least with similar components and usages, Kind cluster, the catalog installer script, etc)? Seems like it would be more likely to result in a reproducer and be something folks can work on.

skattoju commented 5 days ago

Hi Brett, there is not yet an e2e test for this scenario, I guess it will get implemented as part of work related to #737 The way the content is watched is changing so this will probably be fixed when #975 is done.