Vnstat: Statistics tabs not showing

[MichaelTrip]

Important notices Before you add a new report, we ask you kindly to acknowledge the following:

• [ x ] I have read the contributing guide lines at https://github.com/opnsense/plugins/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md
• [ x ] I have searched the existing issues, open and closed, and I'm convinced that mine is new.
• [ x ] The title contains the plugin to which this issue belongs

Describe the bug

When i try to open the Services menu --> VNStat --> Hourly statistics, or daily or monthly or Yearly Statistics, the screen remains empty.

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Go to 'services'
2. Click on 'VnSat'
3. click on 'any of the statistics'
4. Empty

Expected behavior Seeing statistics of vnstat. It is working on the cli though.

Screenshots

Environment

OPNsense 22.7.6-amd64 FreeBSD 13.1-RELEASE-p2 OpenSSL 1.1.1q 5 Jul 2022

[patschi]

Do you have more than 4 interfaces selected in the vnstat settings? I know there's some known restriction/bug that when you select too much interfaces, it stops working. Apparently some *nix-kernel restriction, if I recall.

Seeing statistics of vnstat. It is working on the cli though.

What is the exact command you're running on the CLI?

[MichaelTrip]

Do you have more than 4 interfaces selected in the vnstat settings? I know there's some known restriction/bug that when you select too much interfaces, it stops working. Apparently some *nix-kernel restriction, if I recall.

I have selected al of my 10 interface. I have now selected only 4 of them. Still no change.

Seeing statistics of vnstat. It is working on the cli though.

What is the exact command you're running on the CLI?

just running vnstat

root@OPNsense:~ # vnstat

                      rx      /      tx      /     total    /   estimated
 enc0:
       Oct '22           0 B  /         0 B  /         0 B  /     --     
     yesterday           0 B  /         0 B  /         0 B
         today           0 B  /         0 B  /         0 B  /     --     

 igb0:
       Oct '22      1.17 TiB  /    1.25 TiB  /    2.42 TiB  /    3.03 TiB
     yesterday    118.78 GiB  /   99.10 GiB  /  217.89 GiB
         today    121.04 GiB  /  122.21 GiB  /  243.25 GiB  /  288.29 GiB

 igb0_vlan1100:
       Oct '22           0 B  /         0 B  /         0 B  /     --     
     yesterday           0 B  /         0 B  /         0 B
         today           0 B  /         0 B  /         0 B  /     --     

 etc..

[DjSni]

here too have the same issue

[OPNsense-bot]

This issue has been automatically timed-out (after 180 days of inactivity).

For more information about the policies for this repository, please read https://github.com/opnsense/plugins/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md for further details.

If someone wants to step up and work on this issue, just let us know, so we can reopen the issue and assign an owner to it.

[QuarkZ26]

Please reopen this, it's still hasn't been fixed. Or provide an alternative.

[mimugmail]

Its a problem of vnstat itself

[mpfusion]

I'm having the same problem and can reproduce it with OPNsense 24.1.1-amd64 and vnStat 2.11. I've selected a single interface and the tabs are empty. The vnstat command does produce output, so that's working.

I'm surprised to see this bug closed if it's still an unsolved issue.

[QuarkZ26]

It's actually working now for me, though I don't really know why since I hadn't used it since it was broken. I reinstalled Opnsense from scratch at some point and it's likely the reason.

A few days ago, I decided to try again, installed the plugin, deselected/reselected WAN in the options, and it's working. If it's not working for you, then I'm guessing there's some remnant files that needed cleaned up on the system itself.

[mpfusion]

I reset the config and now the stats appear, indeed. This sadly deleted the history, though. But at least the stats show up now.

[vergoh]

Do you have more than 4 interfaces selected in the vnstat settings? I know there's some known restriction/bug that when you select too much interfaces, it stops working. Apparently some *nix-kernel restriction, if I recall.

Mainly for future reference, this limitation was caused by the interface name being limited to 31 characters which often resulted in around 4 interfaces being the limit when the interface1+interface2+... syntax was used (which is something this plugin does). This limitation no longer exists start from vnStat 2.10.

Its a problem of vnstat itself

As already pointed out, vnstat will still produce results from CLI which suggests the issue is somewhere in the plugin's implementation.

I reset the config and now the stats appear, indeed.

I've tried to understand how the plugin has been implemented and "Reset" appears to only be removing the database directory and then proceeding the same flow as pressing "Save" would. There aren't any plugin related files being stored in vnStat's database directory so it's rather strange "Reset" would result in the situation something fixing itself, unless it's somehow some file/directory permission issue. In that case, one of the system logs should contain some error message indicating what the issue is.

[lexxxel]

Do you have more than 4 interfaces selected in the vnstat settings? I know there's some known restriction/bug that when you select too much interfaces, it stops working. Apparently some *nix-kernel restriction, if I recall.

Mainly for future reference, this limitation was caused by the interface name being limited to 31 characters which often resulted in around 4 interfaces being the limit when the interface1+interface2+... syntax was used (which is something this plugin does). This limitation no longer exists start from vnStat 2.10.

I have this issue with one single interface. I added a second WAN and whenever I switch over to that OR any other interface except the original WAN, I see empty tabs. Only if I select the first WAN, I do get the tabs with the correct tables.

Turns out, vnstat interface might not correlate with the options given in opnsense. For example, I have an PPPoE connection via a VLAN and that interface is the same as my LAN. If I select that PPPoE interface, I will get an empty response. If you have this error, run vnstat on the machine and check if the interface match with the selected ones in the opnsense UI or run vnstat -h and see if you get an error.