Open reschke opened 2 years ago
cc @jbonofre
@reschke Does downgrading Swissbox in 4.13.6-SNAPSHOT also fix the issue?
I don't quiet understand the question - the bug report is for what's current in "master"; and that hasn't changed since Nov 2021.
There is a regression in versions newer 4.13.3 which could be the same or similar and prevents me from upgrading Pax Exam in several Sling projects. Never mind, I will investigate when back at desk.
Yes, I believe we talk about the same regression (or multiple ones).
Just checking: is anybody actually working actively on pax-exam?
Not that I'm aware of depending on your needs osgi-test might be a more lightweight alternative:
but it is all open source so if you want open a PR with a fix and I think it could be merged without much issues,
@reschke I intended to do some work around junit 5 support and relatives, however ended up not doing so yet. Mean while other project where I worked with where I expected to see more pax-exam decided to go with test containers as a more consistent way for testing multiple things. We do have some Karaf integration tests, which normally would work with pax: https://github.com/OpenNMS-Cloud/lokahi/blob/v0.0.42-dev/minion/docker-it/src/test/java/org/opennms/horizon/dockerit/testcontainers/TestContainerRunnerClassRule.java
Main difference there is - you can verify system behavior. If you are still interested in asserting internal state of framework or supplied extensions - exam or tools pointed by @laeubi is way to go, as it will give you access to all low level details. For any system level testing test-containers will do the job. I hope to put some more effort into ConnectorIO/connectorio-addons#5 in July and make it a drop-in replacement of higher level tests.
FYI, I've extracted some of the code from that repository into separate repository. I made also an attempt to separate container handling from customization (what we know as exam options) so they can be applied across different distributions. I'll continue working on it further: https://github.com/ConnectorIO/connectorio-testcontainers and try to see how it will work with integration tests for openHAB (readme is missing for now ;-)).
@reschke, Were you able to identify the change in Swissbox which is causing the issue?
@reschke, Were you able to identify the change in Swissbox which is causing the issue?
Nope.
Downgrading the swissbox dependency to 1.8.3 fixes the issue (that is, reverting #1021)