optimamodel / optima

Optima HIV software tool
http://optimamodel.com
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
7 stars 1 forks source link

Penalty = 0 #1877

Closed kelvinburke closed 1 year ago

kelvinburke commented 1 year ago

However, I am also skeptical of the penalty = 1e9 which is added to the outcome, if the any one of the outcomes like inci is worse than inci in the optimization baseline, even if the sum of inci and death would be lower. So this could make outcomes that should be lower, actually higher. eg baseline inci: 1000, death:200 => total = 2000 (using 1:5 ratio), trial inci: 1001, death: 199 should give total = 1996 which would be better, but instead gives total > 1e9 since 1001 > 1000 The algorithm just seems to act on a if the new total outcome > best total outcome do X, otherwise do Y, which I think it should. So I think the penalty should amount certainly be set to 0. Although why was it put in, in the first place?