search

oracle / graal

GraalVM compiles Java applications into native executables that start instantly, scale fast, and use fewer compute resources 🚀
https://www.graalvm.org
Other
20.37k stars 1.63k forks source link

`gu install python` fails, python is not in `gu available` for graalvm-ce-java16-21.1.0 #3600

Closed paulvi closed 3 years ago

paulvi commented 3 years ago

Describe the issue I am trying latest GraalVM graalvm-ce-java11-21.1.0 and graalvm-ce-java16-21.1.0 on mac, and they both fail to install Python 

gu install python
Downloading: Component catalog from www.graalvm.org
Error: Unknown component: python

https://www.graalvm.org/python/quickstart/ exactly says to use gu install python

gu available also does not show Python component:

$ gu available
Downloading: Component catalog from www.graalvm.org
ComponentId              Version             Component name                Stability                     Origin 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
llvm-toolchain           21.1.0              LLVM.org toolchain            Experimental                  github.com
native-image             21.1.0              Native Image                  Experimental                  github.com
nodejs                   21.1.0              Graal.nodejs                  Experimental                  github.com
R                        21.1.0              FastR                         Experimental                  github.com
wasm                     21.1.0              GraalWasm                     Experimental                  github.com

After installing llvm-toolchain (with gu install llvm-toolchain) that Python is dependent, Python is still not available.

Steps to reproduce the issue Please include both build steps as well as run steps

  1. get, install new GraalVM instance
  2. gu install python

Describe GraalVM and your environment:

More details I guess this is some kind of network or downloads server issue, so I tag it as today 2021-7-18 17:00 UTC0

rodrigar-mx commented 3 years ago

Hi @paulvi. I have just downloaded and installed again graalvm 21.1.0 (java 11 based), and then installed llvm-toolchain + python with gu command on MacOS BigSur and did not have any problem. Let me investigate if there is any issue with Catalina version or it was a temporary server issue as you have already commented. Can you confirm your GraalVM Updater is 21.1.0 version.

paulvi commented 3 years ago

I have 2 Mac notebooks with Catalina, and it works OK on first one, then problem is on my second (home) one. So Mac OS version should not be related.

On moth notebooks I am trying the latest 21.1 

gu --version
GraalVM Updater 21.1.0

I saw, 21.2 is expected within weeks, so I am going to see how different components will be updated

paulvi commented 3 years ago

I tried again, so it works in graalvm-ce-java11-21.1.0 and not in graalvm-ce-java16-21.1.0 (11 vs 16)

graalvm-ce-java11-21.1.0

pauls-mbp:~ paulverest$ which gu
/Users/paulverest/opt/graalvm-ce-java11-21.1.0/Contents/Home/bin/gu
pauls-mbp:~ paulverest$ gu list
ComponentId              Version             Component name                Stability                     Origin 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
graalvm                  21.1.0              GraalVM Core                  -                             
js                       21.1.0              Graal.js                      Supported                     
pauls-mbp:~ paulverest$ gu install
Missing filename(s) of component bundle(s) to install.
pauls-mbp:~ paulverest$ gu available
Downloading: Component catalog from www.graalvm.org
ComponentId              Version             Component name                Stability                     Origin 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
espresso                 21.1.0              Java on Truffle               Experimental                  github.com
llvm-toolchain           21.1.0              LLVM.org toolchain            Supported                     github.com
native-image             21.1.0              Native Image                  Early adopter                 github.com
nodejs                   21.1.0              Graal.nodejs                  Supported                     github.com
python                   21.1.0              Graal.Python                  Experimental                  github.com
R                        21.1.0              FastR                         Experimental                  github.com
ruby                     21.1.0              TruffleRuby                   Experimental                  github.com
wasm                     21.1.0              GraalWasm                     Experimental                  github.com

graalvm-ce-java16-21.1.0

which gu
/Users/paulverest/opt/graalvm-ce-java16-21.1.0/Contents/Home/bin/gu
Pauls-MacBook-Pro:~ paulverest$ gu list
ComponentId              Version             Component name                Stability                     Origin 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
graalvm                  21.1.0              GraalVM Core                  -                             
js                       21.1.0              Graal.js                      Experimental                  
llvm-toolchain           21.1.0              LLVM.org toolchain            Experimental                  github.com
Pauls-MacBook-Pro:~ paulverest$ gu available
Downloading: Component catalog from www.graalvm.org
ComponentId              Version             Component name                Stability                     Origin 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
llvm-toolchain           21.1.0              LLVM.org toolchain            Experimental                  github.com
native-image             21.1.0              Native Image                  Experimental                  github.com
nodejs                   21.1.0              Graal.nodejs                  Experimental                  github.com
R                        21.1.0              FastR                         Experimental                  github.com
wasm                     21.1.0              GraalWasm                     Experimental                  github.com
rodrigar-mx commented 3 years ago

Thank you @paulvi. GraalVM distributions based on Oracle JDK 16 and OpenJDK 16 are currently under development and provided for evaluation and testing purposes (see known-issues). The python extension is not available for JDK16 distributions. We suggest you using JDK11. Indeed, GraalVM 21.2.0 is released today (2021-07-20).

paulvi commented 3 years ago

From https://www.graalvm.org/release-notes/21_2/

Java 16 support: GraalVM builds based on Oracle JDK 16 or OpenJDK 16 remain experimental in this release, but have become more “mature” by overcoming some known limitations and adding support for Ruby, Python, and WebAssembly runtimes.

So Python on JDK16-based GraalVM is from 21.2 only

paulvi commented 3 years ago

Though actually there's no downloads for java8 or java16 in https://github.com/graalvm/graalvm-ce-builds/releases/tag/vm-21.2.0

rodrigar-mx commented 3 years ago

Hi @paulvi. The CE builds for Java 8 and 16 will be published next week.

paulvi commented 3 years ago

Hooray