orcoastalmgmt / orSeaSketch

Repo for tracking issues with Oregon SeaSketch
1 stars 0 forks source link

Average Depth Report - minimum depth is positive number #9

Closed mmosesOCMP closed 4 years ago

mmosesOCMP commented 4 years ago

Minimum depth is positive number, sometimes greater than the veg line or extreme high water line, and unclear whether it is excluding data from offshore rocks and islands, which would be under USFWS jurisdiction and technically not the state.

tchaddad commented 4 years ago

Steps to reproduce:

problem_with_depth_calculation

tchaddad commented 4 years ago

This one is for the SeaSketch team

mmosesOCMP commented 4 years ago

image

It seems as though minimum depth is calculating from the unclipped polygons. If this is the case, it would be preferable to calculate only from the clipped polygon.

We should also add the following explanatory text above the report: "Positive values for minimum depth represents elevation above mean lower low water."

tchaddad commented 4 years ago

We think this is happening because we are using a 100m grid for the bathy, and so for areas with cliffs, the calculations may be producing high positive numbers simply because we are catching the cliff in the cells on the landward side of the clip.

Only the SeaSketch team can confirm if the calculation is being performed on the pre- or post- clipped polygon. Obviously we prefer using the clipped polygon.

TEXT TO ADD TO REPORT: "Positive values for minimum depth represents elevation above mean lower low water. Unusually high values indicate cliff edges that fall within 100m of Mean High Water."

danyocum commented 4 years ago

We always use the clipped sketches in the report calculations, so its post-clipped. The data file I'm using for the bathymetry is:

PHY_Bathymetry100m_ATSML_2011_clipped

danyocum commented 4 years ago

I've added the text to the report.